Declaration of an assembly of 3000 on Saturday 28th May:
For a long time now, decisions are taken for us, without us.
We are workers, unemployed, pensioners, youth who came to Syntagma to struggle for our lives and our futures.
We are here because we know that the solution to our problems can only come from us.
We invite all Athenians, the workers, the unemployed and the youth to Syntagma, and the entire society to fill up the squares and to take life into its hands.
There, in the squares, we shall co-shape all our demands.
We call all workers who will be striking in the coming period to end up and to remain at Syntagma.
We will not leave the squares before those who lead us here leave first: Governments, the Troika, Banks, Memorandums and everyone who exploits us.
We tell them that the debt is not ours.
DIRECT DEMOCRACY NOW!
EQUALITY – JUSTICE – DIGNITY!
The only defeated struggle is the one that was never given!
I heard from a contact that last night in Syntagma Square there were about 50,000 people, everyone occupying it, while excluding all the political parties. There were 2-3000 people in a big assembly, definitely some anarchists, but overall people who are outside any scene. This was the 5th night. The decisions of the assembly (including its statements and its exclusion of fascists) have been really exciting. The big decision last night was not only to continue the occupation and assembly of this square, which is in front of the Greek Parliament, but also, starting today, to occupy many of the smaller squares in the neighborhoods, and begin assemblies there to begin self-organizing locally. Another thing posed by the central assembly is a self-organized, indefinite wildcat general strike, as opposed to the symbolic strikes organized by the big unions, but it's not clear if this is yet anywhere close to realistic.
the spreading of the Spanish
the spreading of the Spanish assemblies to Greece is possibly the greatest thing to happen this year.
very exciting stuff.
Reuters: Quote: Greeks vent
Reuters:
P.S. One of the leading people who has provoked all this is now under house arrest in his $30,000 per month flat in New York accused not of raping whole countries, but of oral rape of one specific proletarian. It's as if Adolf Hitler were arrested just for bombing Coventry cathedral.
(please don't accuse me of using standard Godwin's law: stylistic comparisons of fascistic behaviour with fascism does not mean that I think all forms of capitalism boil down to being the same as Auschwitz).
Is there a decent account of
Is there a decent account of events in Greece since late 2008? Are there any regular posters on Libcom based in Greece? It'd be good to get somebody from Greece to do a short speaking tour around Britain. Do peopel have any good contacts?
www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/
www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/
has updates and some translations, supporting the occupation but critically.
http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/
is another good site and so far seems much more negative about the occupation (for example translating this text http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/2011/05/26/how-many-friends-does-the-compulsive-pacifism-have-on-facebook/ )
Judging from their reports on athens indymedia a lot of politicised anti-authoritarians are disapointed with the occupation, for being pacifist and too vague politically verging on naive reformism (something which is also applied to the spanish movement) but also for the patriotic elements (greek flags, singing the national anthem, etc), this seems very different to the spanish case, also a lot of older people are present in Greece while in spain it seems more of a youth movement. This rejection does not apply to everyone though and some anarchists are posting reports from the assemblies (my impression is that many people present at the occupation dont participate in the assembly).
(Edit: have just re-read my post and I realize I am only talking about the occupation of syntagma square in athens, but it is happening in other parts of greece too which I havent mentioned at all).
(T La Palli occupied london is a good site for looking at the history of events since 2008 (they are based in the UK and might be interested in speaking), Also libcom has had some very good coverage too.
I am a native Greek speaker but haven't lived in Greece for some years now.)
This article is a good
This article is a good summary up to the end of 2010
http://libcom.org/library/burdened-debt-tptg
T La Palli and anybody else
T La Palli and anybody else who has missed out on some of this:
check out the track of taxikipali and this list of stuff from the TPTG;
plus these:
http://libcom.org/forums/news/greece-reflections-some-contradictions-movement-there-10012010
http://libcom.org/library/if-you-want-peace-prepare-class-war-tptg
http://libcom.org/forums/news/greek-journalist-killed-suspected-terrorist-group-attack-19072010
http://libcom.org/news/tptg-%E2%80%9Cthere%E2%80%99s-only-one-thing-left-settle-our-accounts-capital-its-state%E2%80%99%E2%80%99-16032010
http://libcom.org/forums/news/3-deaths-athens-05052010
http://libcom.org/news/greece-new-measures-have-been-voted-second-day-demonstrations-07052010
http://libcom.org/forums/news/another-dead-activist-greece-18032009
http://libcom.org/news/anarchist-killed-greek-police-11032010
an insurrectionary anarchist
an insurrectionary anarchist view on the situation in greece: http://news.infoshop.org/article.php?story=20100625000544521
Latest blog from occupied
Latest blog from occupied london.
Quote: 50,000 people in
from "From the Greek Streets" posted early this morning.
Possibly there are more than 50,000, because the square only holds 50,000 comfortably and on Sunday a friend reports that there must have been an extra 20,000 - 25,000 in the streets around, with 50,000 in the square itself.
This friend reports that on Sunday, the assembly was probably around 3,500. Apparently the camp was started by people into Castoriadis/Cardan, with an ideology of pacifism, direct democracy, liberalism to libertarian communism...explicitly "apolitical", with no banners or flags, though a few (very few) Greek flags were seen, mainly because people were buying them off immigrants trying to make a bit of money fly pitching.
Obviously it's a big mix, with lots of people going as families, showing their opposition (though not doing very much or participating in the assembly) in a strolling around holiday atmosphere. A lot of music, chanting, and slogans against politicians.
One of the bad aspects of the assembly has been a vote for a Committee to Audit the Debt, a meticulous accounting of how much the debt is due to corruption and fraud and how much it's due to pension funds and 'social benefits', a legalistic mentality that leads to reliance on left liberal financial specialists and completely misses the point.There's also been some
leftist manipulation (trots, ex stalinists etc) of who would be allowed to talk, though this has succeeded only in some instances . The ideology of "apolitics" merans that there's been a lot of self-censorship, with people putting their political identity aside, hiding their group ID to present themselves as the common wo/man. There's a lot of "citizenist" ideology - "we're all human beings", though sometimes this is a reaction against defining oneself according to political ideology and/or one's Union identity. In the couple of weeks or so in December 2008 what was particularly refreshing was the fact that people were connecting with people outside of their specific political or Union family/clan/clique, and this "citizenist" ideology is an attempt to somehow artificially recreate this; so it's more complex than simply liberalism taking hold of people's brains.
The good side has been the new fresh feeling that everybody can talk and a lot of people are talking about the miserable contradictions of their daily lives, the financial hell, their own personal debts, the feeling that they have suddenly lost control of their lives (how much they had control previously is another question). Each person is given a time limit of 3 or 4 minutes. There's been a vote for smaller assemblies - around specific topics. This includes voting for proposed actions such as how not to pay for electricity and transport etc. and how to not pay personal debts.
The talk of a general wildcat strike seems to be a bit of leftist voluntarism, hoping to push for these ideas in the one day official strikes coming up, largely against further privatisation, amongst post office workers, Telecom workers and dockers.
Like in Spain, there have been some anarchists who've been very dismissive of this camp, the occupation of the square and of the assemblies, some saying it's a safety valve, a recuperation of the genuine struggle (which usually boils down to only what they're doing). But they don't see what's happening as a process, that if people are starting to break with their passivity it's an opportunity to break out of the anarcho/anti-authoritarian clique ghetto without compromising one's point of view (though sometimes it doesn't make sense to constantly hammer home the same angry "message" in the same old way: communication is a constant struggle and experiment of trial and error, no single repeated form or content connects). Some of them have over-emphasised the presence of Greek flags as proof of the uselessness of this occupation, without understanding how - for the most part, at least - unimportant the rare instances of flag waving (often by kids whose parents just bought one off an immigrant) are.
Nevertheless, anti-authoritarians are right to be angry about some aspects of the occupation/assembly, illustrated by the following:
On Sunday a 15 yr old immigrant stole a bag from a woman in the square and was caught. The woman didn't want him handed over to the cops by the "self-defence" committee. But the most prominent member of the "co-ordination committee" took a personal initiative to hand the kid over, without the woman knowing, and without anybody else (apart from the leftists in the self-defence committee and in the co-ordination committee) knowing. The leftists ( a coalition of various social democratic minded ex-maoists and others) had kept quiet about this, hid it from the assembly, and a middle-of-the-night demo to get the kid released was somehow sabotaged by this clique (who, because of the "apolitical" ideology, have kept quiet about their politics). This has pissed off a helluva lot more people than just the anarcho-insurrectionists who dismiss the whole thing as recuperation and it remains to be seen how these contradictions within the assembly/occupation get played out.
Hopefully the facts here are all correct, and that they correct some of the facts in my OP. I should emphasise that all this information was gathered over the phone from a friend whose general social critique I thoroughly respect, and that any possible errors are largely mine in not having completely understood the situation.
Another comment in
Another comment in spanish:
http://www.alasbarricadas.org/noticias/?q=node/17796
Critical (excessively and
Critical (excessively and rather dogmatically so, imo: compare, for example, with this far more nuanced look at the assemblies in Spain) take on the occupation here in French:
Machine translation:
Plus an appeal for solidarity, also in French:
Machine translation:
Apologies for the uncorrected machine translation, but i don't have the time to go through it all for the moment.
Samotnaf, I already posted a
Samotnaf, I already posted a link for that first article properly translated into english http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/2011/05/26/how-many-friends-does-the-compulsive-pacifism-have-on-facebook/
Here is the second one in a better translation from the group's blog
http://eleftheriakoi-en.blogspot.com/2011/05/greece-urgent-call-for-international.html
Sorry about that - hadn't
Sorry about that - hadn't looked at that link (in fact, got it confused with a later link).
Latest from occupied London,
Latest from occupied London, to cheer you up this Friday morning:
Sunday saw the biggest rally
Sunday saw the biggest rally in this round of protests. ROAR reports, and so does From The Greek Streets. There will be another general strike on Jun 15th, and I read in the second linked articel that there is a call to block parliament from the day before that. With at least 100.000, and possibly up to half million, people on the streets, and new action being planned, the Greek events deserve maybe a bit more attention by communists/ anarchists than they are actually getting.
Quote: the Greek events
I agree - but I think a lot of revolutionaries of whatever label (or none) feel kind of overwhelmed by new events and the need to further nuance their take on things, preferring to either wait till things have "settled", or to just safely look at the most "objective" aspects (eg economic developments) or merely to keep silent for fear of being quickly out of date; but it's only by making new mistakes - including tentative analyses - that this movement will advance and face the immensity of its tasks and desires....
and obviously it's certainly not just confined to Greece, but becoming - in all its different elements of history, culture and political-economy - a world movement that could be as big as '68 or 1917, or bigger, at least a year from now if not sooner...
Quote: Last night (June 11th)
- from On the Greek Streets (occupied London).
- from here.
Mute's blog about Greece:
Mute's blog about Greece: http://www.metamute.org/en/news_and_analysis/updates_from_the_greek_squares_people_s_assemblies_neighbourhoods_and_workplaces
Busy day in Greece
Busy day in Greece today.
Streamed coverage from occupiedlondon
bbc coverage
Grauniad
fave pic so far:
"Call that a baton? That's not a baton. This is a baton!"
Heavy cop attacks with brutal
Heavy cop attacks with brutal injuries, the luxurious Hotel Prince George and the Ministry of Economics attacked by protesters, occupations...
BBC General Strike Image
BBC General Strike Image Gallery
seems like the state repression and escalation of protest is radicalising the assemblies and demonstrators...
the occupied london updates are invaluable
also this:
Occupied London
Will be interesting to see what resolutions are passed...
From
From metamute
More from 'Occupied
More from 'Occupied London':
Article on Greek protests by
Article on Greek protests by members of the Occupied Londen collective... on Aljazeera. And yes, they provide a link to Occupied Londen as well:-)
48-hour strike called to
48-hour strike called to coincide with the parliamentary vote over the next bail-out.
Occupied London
I wonder if there'll be
I wonder if there'll be overlap with June 30th.. fingers crossed!
Quote: Fears that a
- from here.
Sam, that's a really
Sam, that's a really interesting quote (though I suspect it's really what a lot of us are thinking anyway..).. it definitely feels like Greece is on its way to defaulting.. but to be honest I don't have the economic knowledge to even begin predicting what that will mean.. any thoughts from more knowledgable people? I mean, maybe the Euro will collapse but even with this, beyond seeing stuff like Lira or whatever come back, I don't really know what the actual affects will be for workers.. also, if Greece defaults, will that just affect Greece or will other countries go-under as well (I guess French and German banks won't fancy pinning more money on Portugal).. anyway, loads of questions!
Last thing, I've read a lot of stuff about all the street confrontations in Greece, and strikes etc but I've not read very much about the 'I Won't Pay' movement.. they seem pretty interesting but all I've found has been some shitey articles on different mainstream news sites (like this one, which goes on about 'bleary-eyed communists' and the reckless free-loading spirit of the Greeks!)..
They seem pretty cool though, stopping people from paying for public transport, motorway tolls and even medical bills.. anyone got any more information about them?
I too don't have the economic
I too don't have the economic knowledge to even begin predicting what that will mean, but I'd guess it would mean an even greater crisis for the proletariat of Europe - even greater competition between the different capitalist economies, greater pay cuts, etc.
This is totally off the top of my head - me thinking out loud, and it's intellectually intuitive speculation that I won't defend if someone comes up with a dismissive take that clarifies it all, but....
I was wondering if part of the attack on Greece (apart from the fact that this is a counter-attack by the ruling society against the uprising in 2008 and its consequences, plus a way of undermining the margin of freedom that workers in Greece still have as a result of almost all extended families having some independence from the world market by having access to/ownership of land where they can grow their own stuff) is a war of the US against the eurozone. There are some conspiracy theories doing the rounds that the arrest of Strauss-Kahn was because he was pushing for an IMF attack on the US similar to the attack on Greece. Of course, like virtually all conspiracy theories, this has little evidence to back it up and besides, there's nothing nowadays that isn't the object of a conspiracy theory ("why did my cat get hit by a car?") and of course, such a hypothetical decision to impose even greater austerity measures on the US than Walker & co are devising, would be a collective decision, but it certainly helps the very weak US economy vis a vis Europe, though not of course, against China (which, itself, is advancing on its control of the Greek economy). Sure, the fact that - as a possible threat by the US to other leading IMF members (the IMF is not totally under the control of the US - it has a considerable degree of independence from any particular national ruling class) if they try to do a Greece on the US - the consequence is temporarily helpful to the US doesn't prove a conspiracy. But fuck the conspiracy angle: the reality is that the strategy of each national ruling class and the rulers collectively even if opposed to each other is to make cash and potential (hierarchical) order from chaos, and all these economic manipulations are as important for their future as the very real possibility of a nuclear war (probably confined to the middle east) as a way of repressing, derailing and diverting the slow and sometimes not so slow build- up towards a global contestation of class power....
Well, that's quite a big bit of speculation - but what do people think?
No great insights
No great insights but...
There's a theory that through credit default swaps the US economy, already extremely fragile, could be the first victim of a default. The consequences for the European economies are somewhat unknowable but must be devastating (known unknown) particularly for the Irish, Portugese and so on. But all the national economies inside and outside the euro would take a hit. The consequences of an unmanaged default would throw the banking system back into a severe Lehmann-style crisis as banks, unsure of each other, would refuse to believe or lend on others' balance-sheets (unknown unknowns).
A middle to longer-term consequence would be the strengthening of "each for themselves" as each national capital tried to gain some advantage against their rivals through competitive devaluations and so on, strengthening an already existing trend of protectionism (which led to World War II out of the expression of the crisis of the 1930s).
The working class and the poor would obviously suffer the worst because they will inevitably ending up paying for it through higher direct and indirect taxation. But roll on the crisis and all strength and solidarity to the working class in Greece for refusing to pay for the crisis of capitalism.
My point is that greek
My point is that greek anarchists need a kind of programme. It is important to know what to do collectivelly, as a political, social, economic movement. Greece is an state with some structural problems that anarchist should start to think how an anarchist society is possible in Greece. It is important to have a proper strategy for the months to come, in case of worst-scenario. What is the anarchist movement doing to empower people? to build a popular alternative to State and capitalism? Are anarchists participating in the mass assemblies of Syntagma?
I mean, the communist party for sure has its own strategical plan. I imagine they don't want power right now because it's a big shit (they should quit Greece from UE and things like that) and it is probably not very popular.
very exciting stuff.
very exciting stuff.
Hi all, first time poster.
Hi all, first time poster. Thanks to everyone who has posted on this thread, a really great resource for newbies like myself.
I would be interested to know about any solidarity movements in the UK for Greece. Seems to me this is an important time to be forging international bonds?
From "From the Greek
From "From the Greek Streets/Occupied London":
Anatta: unless I hear otherwise, I'd say that any information about solidarity movements you'd get from "From the Greek Streets/Occupied London"; but it seems obvious that the best form of solidarity, like charity, begins at home, fighting for what you want against what you don't; although information and analysis of Greece is also a form of solidarity, it's what is applicable to our own situation that provokes the best forms of "solidarity", applying it to our own struggles.
I was wondering if anybody felt that if/when Greece defaults, that that will actually help to temporarily satisfy the more conservative elements in the assemblies/occupations, give a breathing space to the Greek state. Any speculations?
A blog post from June 18,
A blog post from June 18, 2011. Democracy vs Mythology: The Battle in Syntagma Square
http://sturdyblog.wordpress.com/2011/06/18/democracy-vs-mythology-the-battle-in-syntagma-square/
What makes this really exciting for me is recognizing that, from here in North America, I can't take part at all...I can read the blogs, share them, and post comments, but the real discussion is taking place in realtime open-air assemblies by the Greeks, for the Greeks. We're all watching from the sidelines while the Greeks work on this mess, and when they figure it out, we hope they'll tell us about it. But any news we get will be after the fact.
This makes an interesting
This makes an interesting comparison of the USA with Greece:
It's not that interesting of course, because it's from a very confused "critical" capitalist perspective that doesn't want to understand anything about class war, but the fact that it mentions that the US may default "in August" is so specific that it implies they might have some inside information (though maybe I'm reading too much into it...?).
A look at the organization
A look at the organization and processes of the "movement of the squares":
The "constant circulation of revocable positions" as a central principle reminds me of Decision making and organisational form.
Samotnaf wrote: but the fact
Samotnaf
It's not really inside information. There is a legal limit to how much money the US treasury department can borrow to pay for stuff (called the "debt ceiling"). Once past the debt ceiling the treasury won't have enough money to pay all of it's bills, which means that it would have to default on some loan payments. Officially they hit that limit last month, however, due to some financial wrangling (temporarily suspending investment into retirement funds) they managed to stave off default until August 2nd. This gives congress a little over a month to raise the ceiling, but their's been serious political deadlock: Democrats wanting to just raise the debt limit while Republicans refuse to do this without really serious spending cuts.
Personally, I'd be shocked if they didn't manage raise the ceiling, as the economic consequences of a default would be enormous, not to mention the political consequences for everybody involved. The entire thing has been a total farce.
JC was asking about external
JC was asking about external exposure to Greece and the other PIGS. I found this graphic from the NYTimes from a while back, a handy way of getting a picture on relative sizes.
PIIGS Debt
(NB, you may need to play around with the CTRL+ & CTLR- a bit to get best readability of text, which is why I didn't insert as graphic - too small to read here). NB the numbers have changed a bit in the interim (and are in $ rather than €)
The general consensus is that the actual level of Greece's external debt (€340bn) is not in itself systemically threatening, but the concern is the effect of the collapse of the Greek banks might set off a chain reaction of CDS held against private loans into those banks (as opposed to sovereign CDS which is currently marginal, only €5bn cleared, and - unusually for CDS - not expected to be that much more in the OTC market, given that the hedge funds and other players have moved away from sovereign CDS, as they expect the EU to move the goalposts to cheat on what counts as a credit event for these instruments - there's current a small war going on between the raters - S&P, Moodys, Fitches - and the ECB over this). The big worry (for them) would be if the knock-on effects took Spain down and made Italy the next domino. The "nuclear option" would be the possibility of another generalised "fear of the dark" seize up in the interbank lending market, if the threat of losses occuring without players knowing who's holding the parcel, but so far the LIBOR-OIS spread - which is a measure of stress in the interbank lending market - seems fairly flat).
But, as Gillian Tett (the assistant editor of the FT), of all people, said the other night on Newsnight, this is not an economic crisis, but a political one - will Europe go for further integration or disintegration? And, as we might add, whose integration is it anyway? But that's a whole other essay...
On the same Newsnight
On the same Newsnight programme that Ocelot refers to above there was another financial druid who stated, quite correctly, that this wasn't a "second" Lehman's but just a continuation of the same fundamental economic crisis which is unresolved and continuing to deepen. Contrarily to the 2008 near-meltdown there seems to be even less "coordination and cooperation" between the all the national capitals as economic tensions rise between those countries within the eurozone, tensions between those inside and outside and immediate tensions between the US and the ECB (personified in the new IMF leadership). Another factor that's somewhat different than 2008 is the active role of the working class, whatever the weaknesses of the movement, in refusing to take any more austerity and pay for the crisis of capitalism - it's what it is driven to do. The vast national campaigns - anti-Greek in Germany, anti-German in Greece, anti-EU from the outside, and so on, all have a material base as far as the respective ruling classes are concerned but are also aimed at mobilising the workers behind "their" national interests and thus against any incipient expressions of an international class.
Link to updates on the 48
Link to updates on the 48 hour General Strike starting now.
And from here:
Quote: Police in Athens have
- here.
and more: Quote: Violence
and more:
Some riot porn photos here.
Some riot porn photos here.
I liked this one: Bringing
I liked this one:
Bringing back 'Suck it!' ;)
Today's Daily Mail. And
Today's Daily Mail.
And there's this excellent comment in The Guardian of all places:
I'm hearing at the moment the
I'm hearing at the moment the police has follow the protesters into the metro tunnel and are firing tear gas into it and firing rubber bullets too.. there will be a lot injured people down there....
Quote: Greek police fired
- here.
- here.
Various live streamings.
Giving the cops the
Giving the cops the finger:
(here).
Depressing humanist crap.
Fortunately there have been loads of other stuff going on:
-Occupied London.
Thanks for keeping updating
Thanks for keeping updating this thread, very interesting!
On a comment on the Occupied London someone said
I haven't seen any reports of people dying, yet, is it confirmed? God it makes me so sick, I fucking hate police. How can lefty-liberals in UK and wherever else see what police are doing in Greece and still maintain support for the police? Equally, there were loads of police at stuff today who were saying how they support the strikes and are against the cuts, etc. - wtf?!
Their is no report of a death
Their is no report of a death in Athens. On the other hand in many cases people could have died yesterday from gas-suffocation.
Greek riot police uses deadly strong gas (the term tear-gas is nowhere near the truth) which are mainly made in Israel. In 29/6 they used the largest amount of teargas in the history of this state and I am not exaggerating. The use can only be compared with ... the day before, 28/6 as we had a 48hours general strike with rallys and clashes. They even threw this gas in the subway and in a building.
There where also many incidents where people could have died from been crushed by the crowd during retreats in stairs, dead ends and small streets.
Police in Greece has the sick habit of throwing flashbangs straight in protesters' heads. Those grenades are very strong and the shrapnels they release can at least cause you an eye. People have also lost big percentage of their hearing. They also threw a flashbang in a building but luckily it did not explode. In the pictures in link following you can see (from an older incident) the result of such a grenade in the legs. The guy in the last pic was wearing a typical shoe which was destroyed and had his toes broken (is this the correct syntax?). http://athens.indymedia.org/front.php3?lang=el&article_id=1226184
Greek police has a rather new riot police team, named ΔΕΛΤΑ = DELTA (name inspired by the USA DELTA force?) that use motorcycles. It is similar to the Iranian police. They are also very brutal and when charging they try to run over protesters. Here is an older video. It is not very typical of their tactic, as their charges are more massive, but I chose this because it has a good answer by the defenders. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uk_tubEAk4U&feature=related
Riot police is of course very brutal. Most of the time they use their batons holding they from the opposite end (http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_B2p_sAwKE44/SYcO2pVxzgI/AAAAAAAAILk/bwp10VDSGrM/s1600-h/17950_normal.jpg) to cause more damaged even thought this practice is forbidden by law (irony). They beat up even handcuffed people and kick a lot. They even use their small fire extinguishers to to hit people, practice that can easily crash a skull. Here a video from 11/3/2011 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=otn4Qr3VuBU). A protester was seriously beaten in the head, had to spent 19 day in the hospital, many off them in a comma and the doctors said that he is lucky to be alive. They also throw many big stones to the protesters causing many injuries (http://athens.indymedia.org/front.php3?lang=el&article_id=1313763 pics from 29/6/2011). Furthermore, don't think that they attack only militant youths, they have no problem beating up peaceful elderly people. Last but not least, they must be hating music!!! (http://cryptome.org/info/greece-protest4/pict42.jpg pic from 29/6/2011).
Quote: How can lefty-liberals
The cops in the UK follow a very long tradition of ruling class 2-faced hypocrisy - the diplomacy that stole whole countries and at one time had the biggest Empire in the world, the white men that talked with forked tongue. UK cops have always presented themselves, and been presented by the dominant ideology, as "the best police in the world", apparently unarmed and always ready to help little old ladies across the road. They've always had the best PR in the world. Generally speaking on demos, for instance, they'll have the nice polite police saying in charming dulcet tones, "Will you please move back now", whilst the riot pigs are ready behind these front lines, ready to do their worst if you don't move back. The sickening lefty-liberals seem to be living in a 45 years out-of-date Dixon of Dock Greenland fantasy, where the cop is a patronising avuncular figure giving you directions and telling you the time. I suspect that the loads of cops saying how they support the strikes and are against the cuts, etc. are part of this 2-facedness: if you apparently support the cause (at least until their own position is secured) it's better than a riot shield, disarming any anger before it's even begun to be expressed. How many times have you heard a politician say, "I'm on your side, I agree with you" in order to deflect any flak?
By the way, I hope everybody reading this thread has also read this excellent report, here on libcom.
Giannis wrote: Here is an
Giannis
Hey Giannis, thanks for all that info, interesting (and mental) stuff.. also, in case you didn't already know, that video above did make it to the UK, on the BBC website here.. as you can see, they leave out the bit where he's charging into a crowd on a motorbike and that he's part of a special psycho police unit (I obviously didn't know either until you'd posted up that video).
Sometimes the media is so blatantly disingenuous that I'm actually shocked at my own naivety..
i think that even tops the
i think that even tops the Metro's story of 'anarchists attacking anti-cuts protesters', which turned out to be anarchists attacking known neo-nazis...
Iirc correctly there is a post on the occupied london blog that shows the special helmet insignia one of the bike police units use, which is directly associated with greek fascism...
EDIT:
Occupied London
(from http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2010/12/16/452-more-photos-from-the-general-strike-athens-16-12-2010/ )
giannis wrote: Police in
giannis
I corrected the link above, the previous one was irrelevant.
A new video from 29/6 came out today showing riot policemen throwing stones. In the video you can see the head of that team (the pig without shield) commanding the others to throw more of them (http://athens.indymedia.org/front.php3?lang=el&article_id=1314851 first video).
@Ed, thanks for the info.
@Harrison Myers. Police in Greece is full of fascists. Moreover, for decades now the Greek state and the police collaborate with the fascists secretly and many times they organize attacks together against anarchists or immigrants. Here 's a video, the men among the riot police are members of a neo-nazi group: http://youtu.be/y_pOI0iJ8B4 . The result of that collaboration was few antifascists stubbed.
on the chemical warfare in
on the chemical warfare in athens: http://signalfire.org/?p=12036
according to the union of the
according to the union of the journalists, in 29/6 a reporter suffered complete loss of his hearing from both ears when a flashbang grenade exploded close to him. in addition, he was beaten up by the cops. his hearing has not been restored up to this day.
(No subject)
[youtube]aE3R1BQrYCw[/youtube]
This is not an anti-Semite
This is not an anti-Semite conspiracy theory but I read somewhere that the tear-gas provided by Israel is a particularly noxious variety of this poison.
Quote: At approximately 4.15
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/07/30/syntagma-square-tent-occupation-evicted-by-police-in-the-early-hours-of-saturday/
From mute: Quote: Today at
From mute:
More on the cabbies'
More on the cabbies' strike:
Samotnaf wrote: The strikers
Samotnaf
I don't think I understand this bit. Are the toll booth and ticket office workers part of this strike as well? Are they acting in solidarity? Did the cabbies force them to run for free? Awesome either way though.
I didn't write it, I copied
I didn't write it, I copied it and I read it as that that they'd forced the toll gates and ticket offices to run for free (in Greece the toll gates are very often forced, mainly by irate commuters, to run for free, as the tolls have been increased considerably and more gates have been constructed in areas where people have no chance of getting to work and back home other than through a toll gate; even mayors have participated in these anti-toll gate actions).
Samotnaf wrote: I didn't
Samotnaf
Sorry, I was leaving it open for anybody, I didn't expect that you had the answer. That was helpful, though, and makes a lot of sense.
http://www.grreporter.info/en
http://www.grreporter.info/en/water_jets_and_colored_bullets_protesting_greeks_starting_september/4933
http://www.occupiedlondon.org
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/08/24/greek-parliament-votes-in-education-reform-bill-abolishing-academic-asylum-free-course-readers/
The above text finishes with
The above text finishes with this:
Hot autumn here we come..... globally, locally, personally....
Quote: the Ministry of civil
time for the rainbow bloc
http://www.occupiedlondon.org
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/08/30/at-least-45-university-departments-occupied-by-their-students-in-greece-gearing-up-for-another-winter-of-discontent/
Quote: At least 45 university
that is a good new!
thank you to keep us informed about what goes on in Greece Subprole.
more news: Quote: At least 87
more news:
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/08/31/at-least-87-departments-under-student-occupation-across-greece-with-the-number-increasing-by-the-hour/
news from
news from salonica:
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/09/10/thessaloniki-demonstrations-contrainfo-updates-until-1740-gmt2/
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/09/10/thessaloniki-demonstrations-on-the-day-of-the-international-exhibition-constant-updates-ticker/
Last I heard (Thursday) there
Last I heard (Thursday) there were 300 University occupations - the vast majority of the Universities.
Term for the high schools begins tomorow - who knows what'll happen?
Article on Anarkismo with a
Article on Anarkismo with a critique of the Greek tent protests:
In the struggle between yourself and the world, back the world
Report on major clashes
Report on major clashes mainly in Thessaloniki, Friday night.
And various videos here.
Quote: Today, is the first
- From the Greek Streets, yesterday.
Public sector workers have
Public sector workers have called for strikes on the 6th of October against austerity measures.
From Occupied London: Is this
From Occupied London:
Is this the Greek Poll Tax? Anger mounting in Greece as government attempts taxation through electricity bills
Mainstream media reports:
Pity the Greeks (BBC)
More austerity to avert default (Athens News)
The troika's fifteen commandments (Athens News)
[youtube]ZIdAJNiGYXc[/youtube]
Mark. wrote: I think he
Mark.
I think he says it all when he says in the interest of the nation and the bloc. On a separate note, is it possible there will be the formation of new blocs or is this Utopian?
From the Greek Streets
From the Greek Streets (above) talks about a new tax on property. In Greece between 70% (according to a friend) and 80% (according to the above article) of the people own their own property and/or land. Unlike in the UK, the Greek proletariat is still attached to the land - the vast majority, through their extended family or directly, have land on which they can grow food independently of the market system. Which gives them a greater margin of freedom than the working class in the UK , which have been dispossessed of land since the enclosures. I'd guess that this attack is a modern version of the enclosures. But you can't really compare it with poll tax, as it's dependent on the size of property, whereas poll tax was a tax imposed equally on 4 people living in one bedroom and one person living in a mansion (if they lived in the same borough) - ie each individual would have to pay the same amount.
The Greek State is bringing in an increase in income tax - apparently a "solidarity with the unemployed" tax, though no-one believes this, probably not even those who thought of dressing it up this way. It's an increase of 1% for those with under 20,000 euros p.a., and 2% for everybody over 20,000 euros p.a. (I think this tax increase is specifically for public sector workers, though I'm not sure).
There's going to be a 24-hour school teachers' strike this week, partly because the State is going to HALVE funding for state schools (not wages and salaries, but half funding for everything else - equipment, maintenance, utilities etc.). The State is also going to privatise the financial administration of Universities, and introduce fees for the last year of University courses.
There are so many attacks that people, whilst finding it unbelievable that there seems to be no way of negotiating with the State any more, feel that the State is saying through its policies "Come on - make my day - we're declaring civil war, so let's see some action", maybe hoping for predictable terrorist responses that they can predictably deal with. The "can't pay" movement, though, seems to be one of the more popular responses to these attacks.
Paul Mason: Greece at a
[youtube]_6NhzVf0mIM[/youtube]
Paul Mason: Greece at a decision point
Paul Mason again Quote: In
Paul Mason again
and again another bunch of
and again another bunch of news:
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/09/21/stories-from-the-daily-life-in-greece/
http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/2011/09/20/athens-solidarity-gathering-regarding-the-arson-attack-on-kouvelou-squat/
http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/2011/09/20/corfu-island-cops-raided-elaia-squat/
http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/2011/09/21/greece-mentally-ill-people-are-sent-back-to%E2%80%A6-loony-bins-workers-gear-up-for-anti-government-protests/
Some additional facts about
Some additional facts about the new austerity measures:
You are only entitled to unemployment benefits (for 12 months maximum) if you were on full time employment for an equivalent of 18 months or more (used to be 12).
Even unemployed people who are NOT on benefits are not excluded from the property tax - they will just be asked to pay 0.5 euros per square meter. So, if you have inherited your parents' house, and you are unemployed, but get no benefits, you will still be asked to pay.
Minimum wage in Greece used to be around 700 euros per month; it has now gone to around 590 euros (for full time employment).
Businesses are now allowed to pay young inexperienced employees 20% less than the minimum salary for 2 years (just like the CPE in France in 2006).
Permanent employees who will be fired from the public sector will not receive compensation. They will keep them on hold for 12 months and will be paying them the equivalent of unemployment benefits (i.e. 460 euros). During this time though they will not be counted in the unemployment statistics. After 12 months they will be fired with no entitlement to any compensation.
The state is being asked by the IMF to reduce its expenses and fire public sector workers. But the state's expenses have actually increased in 2011 because of the added expenses of unemployment and housing benefits.
Quote: Greek government
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/09/21/greek-government-announces-yet-another-round-of-cuts-as-unions-announce-general-strikes/
Thousands march in education
[youtube]AlxjUF8Q-Gg[/youtube]
Thousands march in education marches Athens, Thessaloniki and other major Greek cities
Greece hit by one-day transport strike against cuts (video)
Quote: Thousands of Greeks
- from The Guardian.
Air traffic controllers and council workers also went on strike.
Also from that Guardian
Also from that Guardian article:
Students call for
Students call for struggle
Paul Mason: Athenians take to streets amid bailout turmoil (video)
Action against house
Action against house auctions
A video from the action
Clashes in Syntagma,
Clashes in Syntagma, occupation of studio at state TV channel
Paul Mason on Greece's middle classes
Call for Action – The days of
Call for Action – The days of their affluence are just a few!
good to see that some of the
good to see that some of the proletarians in greece understand that the police scum is not part of the working class:
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/09/27/greek-parliament-votes-in-latest-austerity/
+ http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/2011/09/26/greece-the-teaching-system-is-the-teaching-of-system/
School
School occupations
Not very interesting Reuters
Not very interesting Reuters video on the Athens transport strike.
I was wondering if the world's ruling class is treating Greece as a laboratory for future confrontations in other countries. To see how far people can be pushed before they fight back in both predictable and unpredictable ways, to see if people seriously will be pushed into civil war, and how that is managed, so that in other countries what might be unpredictable in Greece, then becomes predictable and maybe more manageable for the ruling class globally. After all, Greece has had significant nation-wide class conflict on and off for almost 40 years and if they can force a full-blown class war there and examine its repercussions, then that would help them in other coutnries. Sure, I know the rulers don't seriously control everything, but they think they can.
Any ideas on this?
Samotnaf wrote: Any ideas on
Samotnaf
I get the impression that the powers that be don't really consider protests and class conflict, in Greece or elsewhere, as a serious threat any more.
-----
Government ministries occupied by employees
-----
How Athens' geography feeds unrest
This article is from a couple of months ago but for anyone unfamiliar with Athens it gives some background on how the layout of the city lends itself to protest.
Quote: I get the impression
Not so sure about that.
I know they've been lulled to sleep by the success of their virtually unstoppable counter-revolution over the last 20 years or more as much as anybody who claims to oppose this society - look at the pre-Millbank posts - here and up until news of the occupation and destruction and the same goes for the scepticism in response to the facebook call-out in Egypt in January - eg Khawaga here. But if many revolutionaries of whatever stripe have begun to wake up since Millbank, Tunisia and Egypt (some before) so have the ruling class - and the prospect of a double/treble/quadruple dip recession and its effect on the class struggle is one of their considerations. Certainly after the experience of 1917,when the rulers generally thought a revolution was unavoidable, and after 1968, when they were forced to concede a lot particularly in France, after being taken by surprise, and yet managed to regain control, or the way that 15 years of revolution in South Africa was repressed by leftism-turned-neo-liberal, they probably think they can ride out any storm.
But I get the feeling that they're not as complacent as you think they are, and that they are constantly trying to prepare again and again for a world of permanently worsening storm and crisis.
Those who seriously believe a revolution is not only desirable and essential but also possible should be doing the same.
Samotnaf wrote: I get the
Samotnaf
Well maybe. It's possible I'm paying too much attention to the liberal commentariat and they certainly don't seem too concerned about threats to the system, other than from the economic crisis itself.
Paul Mason: newsnight report
Paul Mason: newsnight report on Greece (video)
Greek public-sector workers
Greek public-sector workers lock out international financial inspectors
About the TV studio occupation mentioned by Mark the other day: apparently this was carried out by members of a Leftist student union (the EEAAT, I think). Some people who'd been involved in the occupation of a TV studio during the news back in December 2008 offered to give them advice and help with operating all the equipment - cameras, mics, etc., which they knew about and had used back in the uprising in 2008. These Leftists refused the advice, because of fear of the consequences, so none of what they wanted to say (their 'message') was given over the air, which had been done in 2008.
There are about half the Universities occupied that were occupied about a week ago - down from about 300 to about 150, but all the main ones are still in occupation.
As previously mentioned, the senior high school (15 to 18 yr olds) occupations are growing all the time - now over 600 out of a national total of about 2000. These occupations are spreading to junior (11 to 14 yr olds) high schools as well, with a few occupied. The Headmasters/mistresses are calling for parents' meetings where s/he will try to get parents to persuade their kids not to go on strike. This could well backfire, as it gives the parents, who face financial misery along with most of the rest of the population, to get together and meet each other, when normally they wouldn't have such an opportunity.
In Athens, various local (but not national) branches of unions (don't ask me which unions) have vowed to collect tax bills (taxes supposedly to pay for unemployment benefit,presented as ''solidarity" taxes, though nobody believes they are) en masse, go to the local tax offices, and dump them or burn them: some have already done so.
Syntagma Square still has assemblies, though these are constantly attacked by the cops, even whilst people are speaking and debating. Consequently the numbers are way down from June - 2 or 3 thousand nowadays. The cops don't attack, for the moment, the local square occupations - there must be at least 10 in the working class areas of Athens. Nationally, it's hard to get precise information, but there are square occupations in Thessaloniki, Thebes and Crete and other places. The "won't pay" issue is probably the main topic of discussion in these assemblies and in conversations generally - often around the issue of illegality, many people being afraid to break the law, but equally others saying it's the only thing to do.
Little stories from IMF-run
Little stories from IMF-run Greece: People in the northern Greek city of Veria re-connect disconnected electricity… and they explain why
Greek state workers disrupt
[youtube]0SQBWDV5zog[/youtube]
Greek state workers disrupt audit talks, again ----- video
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
[youtube]qKpxPo-lInk[/youtube]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debtocracy
Some mainstream press
Some mainstream press reports
Plan to sack state workers to be unveiled (Reuters)
Government, troika at odds over labour reserve (Reuters)
Greece is slipping into the abyss (Telegraph)
The Telegraph
Despair and resignation as
Despair and resignation as more pain looms (Reuters)
Mark: the article you linked
Mark: the article you linked to - part of the mainstream media - obviously wants to encourage despair and resignation. Today in Greece, tomorrow everywhere. The misery is obvious - the fight against it often censored and distorted. Don't think you should encourage this type of media by giving it attention.
Quote: Police may be called
- http://www.ekathimerini.com/4dcgi/_w_articles_wsite1_1_03/10/2011_409230
Quote: Civil servants staged
http://www.athensnews.gr/portal/1/48504
http://www.athensnews.gr/portal/9/48485
From 25
[youtube]G67fM54Wy9A[/youtube]
From 25 September
http://greece.greekreporter.c
http://greece.greekreporter.com/2011/10/03/troika-wants-greeces-minimum-wage-scrapped/
dp
dp
Quote: Panic on markets
- here.
Occupation last night of two
Occupation last night of two local TV channels in Iraklio, Crete, during the news, with statements read out calling for support for today's general strike.
[youtube]_zeI_pGbRfU[/youtube]
also here
Greece buys 400 tanks from
Greece buys 400 tanks from USA
http://mrzine.monthlyreview.o
http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2011/varoufakis031011.html
+ http://yanisvaroufakis.eu/euro-crisis/
Quote: Clashes in Athens as
- here.
(No subject)
[youtube]Iu1qpXV4OxQ[/youtube]
How are the armed struggle
How are the armed struggle groups doing?
The beating of the guy with
The beating of the guy with the long hair in the middle of the video Mark posted above was horrible. Were the cops just doing it for the benefit of all the cameramen standing around recording it?
Peter - I think this is just
Peter - I think this is just routine and the fact the MAT carried on regardless despite obviously being filmed is an indication that they don't believe there will be any comeback.
The video was posted up on youtube yesterday so I'm assuming the footage is from this week, but there's no description and as far as I can see nothing in the comments to confirm this. From the Greek Streets has some more photos and videos here.
A tweet on Paul Mason's
A tweet on Paul Mason's account: #greece most popular politicians of far right and far left, each with 38%
What are the groups in the anarchist scene over there? How large are they?
dp
dp
Can't answer your question,
Can't answer your question, wojtek - but why do you want to know? Since the early '70s anarchism, with situationist ideas thrown in, has been one of the dominant ideologies in the Greek opposition, and with the movement in December 2008, that's got even bigger - there are now loads and loads of anarchist goups throughout the country, of different tendencies and with varying numbers. Which doesn't necessarily mean they have anything more to say or do than any other groups that want an anti-State revolution.
About the cops going into the Athens metro (see Mark's video): they even beat up tube workers, 15 year old girls, photo journalists and reporters. This happened on Wednesday.
About the schools' occupations: headmasters have been told to grass on leading school students who are occupying their schools; last week there were a couple of schools where the cops went in and arrested the occupiers, who were a minority of school students. Virtually all teachers refuse to inform the cops of who's occupying their school.
wojtek wrote: What are the
wojtek
I've no first hand information but I don't think any of the groups are that big, in the hundreds at most. There's some background, dating from before the current crisis, in this abc thread and a podcast of an interview with a member of the anarcho-syndicalist group ESE here ('in Greece there is a separation between riot anarchism and social anarchism').
Thanks Samotnaf and Mark, I
Thanks Samotnaf and Mark, I was just wondering as you do.
Quote: Tuesday 11/10 starts
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/10/11/macrhes-and-occupations-all-around-athens-today/
Quote: A few hours ago, GENOP
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/10/13/electricity-corporation-union-occupies-building-issuing-property-tax-in-athens-tonight-as-wildcat-occupations-and-strikes-spread-across-the-country/
From the Greek Streets:
From the Greek Streets: coverage of October 19-20 general strike
Athens News: Country heads for standstill before austerity vote
Some mainstream news coverage
Some mainstream news coverage of Greece:
Al-Jazeera: http://english.aljazeera.net/news/africa/2011/10/201110190538784585.html
BBC: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-15366310 & http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-15370881
Judging from this and the Occupied London liveblog it looks like there's been loads of clashes and like EVERYTHING has been shut down (private and public sector)..
One other thing, in one of the BBC videos they mention that France's credit rating has been downgraded.. now if there's anyone else in Europe that's good for a fight it's the French and should austerity hit there in a big way I reckon that we could see serious struggle (moreso than what's been happening in Spain and Portugal) spread across Europe in a big way.. or is that just me?
I think everyone of us is
I think everyone of us is craving for it and pushing in that direction, mate. Right now in Spain we have the calm that precedes the storm, me thinks, due to the next elections and the resistible rise of the partido popular, which shows again that most of the spaniards are still hooked on parliamentary politics. On the other hand the massive saturday demos show that clashes are to be expected as the non-violent approach it's quickly showing itself more and more as a running on the spot thing.
A comment from Richard
A comment from Richard Seymour's blog Lenin's Tomb. RS may have got it from the Guardian's live feed, but I'm not sure:
So, the communist party
So, the communist party stopping the people storming the parliament?
some fucking communists they
some fucking communists they are...
Bunch of videos from
Bunch of videos from yesterday:
[youtube]I5KZXY36Tzk[/youtube]
[youtube]T_gjIWknhT8[/youtube]
[youtube]WIZcdcfIpy0[/youtube]
[youtube]7OM8znTZYkk[/youtube]
[youtube]SSiVl1eScM4[/youtube]
[youtube]SWC7RZpxyl4[/youtube]
Quote: El PAME (KKE) ha
This was posted up on the Greek thread on alasbarricadas. The photos show PAME members protecting parliament today.
Athens News: Second day of general strike as parliament votes
Athens News: Live news blog, Oct. 20
Once again, signs of the so
Once again, signs of the so called "anti cuts movt" fracturing. I think it would be reasonable to expect similar developments in Italy, Spain and even the UK if things continue to escalate.
What were the (stated) reasons behind KKE's move? How popular is the urge to 'defend democracy'? How popular is the (implicit) belief that the 1 million odd in Syntagma Sq were fascistic?
PAME are out again today
PAME are out again today doing the same, probably don't want that state that they intend to 'capture' being damaged right....
OccupiedLondon wrote: 14.59
OccupiedLondon
Ufff. This is looking bad in many ways. But as it now seems, their situation there in the recent times is like a cold civil war (I'm not talking about the anarchist vs. stalinists, but the society as such), flaring up time to time as friction grows. Comrades over there, keep on, but stay safe!
http://www.occupiedlondon.org
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/10/20/live-updates-from-the-general-strike-october-20/
more news on http://en.contrainfo.espiv.net/2011/10/20/greece-october-20th-constant-updates/
Quote: 16.56 Unconfirmed:
according to more recent information by Occupied London and Contra Info not true
Some things never change, I
Some things never change, I guess. Stupid red fascist cunts. Also, to everyone in Greece, I hope you're safe!
http://www.occupiedlondon.org
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/10/20/53-year-old-demonstrator-dead/
Cue media stories of evil
Cue media stories of evil anarcho-fascists murderous attack on loyal communist defenders of Greek democracy and society.
Plus ça change...
Clashes between the stalinists and the rest of the left, anarchists included, have been going on for years, if not decades. But still, in the current climate, the backlash that will certainly come from this may well have a damping effect similar to the death of the 3 bankworkers last year. In these situations, the rights and the wrongs are irrelevant compared to the emotional response produced through the media discourse and popular conversation in public spaces (work, cafes, bars, etc).
What the result will be, we will have to see. But it seems unlikely that the immediate response will be greater class cohesion or sense of shared identity.
A lovely bit of of
A lovely bit of of revisionism from the Morning Star:
Quote: Trade union and
That could be true I guess?
Anatta wrote: Quote: Trade
Anatta
Truly disgusting. The Greek Communist Party (KKE) is the last unreconstructed Stalinist party in Europe. And they are brutal fucking thugs, as bad or worse than the cops.
Yesterday, on the last day of the 48-hour general strike, a KKE member died of a heart attack in the battles with anarchists and other groups opposed to further austerity legislation just passed in Parliament. All this as the KKE union front PAME linked arms and defended the front of the Parliament Building at Syntagma Square. They obviously are angling for more seats in the next election.
Here's the story in Athens News
Hieronymous wrote: Anatta
Hieronymous
LAOS also applauded the actions of PAME/KKE in parliament yesterday - fascists/cops/stalinists united against the whole movement. And also its to be clear that PAME/KKE were attacking everyone including normal citizens. In retaliations last night 3 offices of the KKE in Thessaloniki were attacked by anarchists.
Quote: A lovely bit of of
Innit, I'm refusing to touch copy on the international desk atm.
Rob Ray wrote: Quote: A
Rob Ray
Any possibility of you writing a statement on this? I mean as a person working there? I am not saying you agree with it at all but it may be quiet good to show there is dissent within Morning Star or is this not a good idea?
Decent first person write-up
Decent first person write-up of what happened at Syntagma yesterday on Vice:
http://www.vice.com/en_uk/read/athens-greece-riots-protests-anarchy-communists-syntagma-square-day-two
Anatta wrote: Quote: Trade
Anatta
If it was true (and unfortunately, that is really really far from the truth), then they did a piss poor job of it!
Na they are a parliamentary stalinist group. real life stalinists too :eek:
on the Greek CP:
on the Greek CP: http://internationalviewpoint.org/spip.php?article694 (10 years old but still accurate)
Interestingly Stalin during
Interestingly Stalin during his bolshevik years would have denounced the KKE as reformist.
Lots of double standards. I'm
Lots of double standards.
I'm a greek anarchist.
Some facts:
1)PAME,for a number of years, does its demos in different place & time than all the rest.
Yesterday,they left the familiar path, and decided to occupy the main square outside the parliament.
2)PAME set its block guard surrounding the square,letting nobody in.They also surrounded the parliament.
3)PAME,as any block in a protest, has the right to guard it,control who enters it,and the right to not move and relocate according to the wishes of others.They,as any other, have the right to use violence to repel others from forcefully entering the block.
4)A minority of self proclaimed anarchist,autonomists and other crap are the first who initiated an attack against PAME's block using rocks, pieces of marble and molotov cocktails.
Note:Not only the block's guard, but the people in it as well.
5)The syndicalist of PAME died of heart attack, and the tear gas and chemicals from the police played a role in that.
Some personal opinions:
a)Anyone who actively defends the attack on pame's block, in the way and with the means by which it happened is no comrade of mine,and should be expelled from any decision making process.Do i have to remind you of May 5th 2010?
b)PAME's actions were stupid, committed for public relations, and to "rise up" above the other protesters as order preservers.They blocked the "main stage" of the protest because they could.Although i completely disagree with that action, i fully recognize their right to do so.If it was the other way around, if the PAMEites had tried to enter the square occupied by the rest of the demo and got beaten up everyone would cheer in celebration of the defeat of the stalinists.
that is all
Admin: no flaming.
Admin: no flaming.
Is there any reason to think
Is there any reason to think it's disinformation?
Discussion on the
Discussion on the alasbarricadas thread (google translation) - see posts by CretaNarka
Edit: This wasn't intended as a response to the question from mons, just that I've found the discussion on alasbarricadas more enlightening than the discussion here.
mons wrote: Is there any
mons
Seems less like disinformation and more like an oversimplification of something pretty complex. I'm not going to pretend like I can sort out what happened based on internet reports, but several first hand accounts make it seem pretty clear that the events that evolve is presenting as clear cut and obvious were anything but.
@KriegPhilosophy: That seems really unnecessary.
yeah this isn't
yeah this isn't disinformation, it just seems like bad politics. Point 3 is absurd and it seems like a typical form over content argument. If there were enough Fash out to stop people marching on parliament, would we 'respect' their block? No of course not. This seems to me to be the nub of evolve's argument, that PAME wanted to stop people disturbing the austerity process, therefore they should be allowed to. ludicrous.
As for point 4, a 'minority' of blah, blah, blah, well, we have seen this mdoe of argumentation before and should always be skeptical.
Quote: PAME set its block
....letting in the deputies and then getting their international organisations to say that they surrounded parliament to stop the deputies getting in...a very sick joke.
The vast majority of the people in the square, from what I heard, were really disgusted with PAME. As for the 5th May,invoking that is clearly an attempt to make PAME look like victims, when they were there to try to assert some superiority to the movement and solidify their own base against the anarchists etc. But it backfired, as all the Greek right-wing press and other media are praising PAME for their defence of parliament.
evolve - you have yet to live up to your name.
Statement by the KKE
Statement by the KKE
[youtube]qxba6jjAdW0[/youtube]
Thanks Mark, that alasbarricadas discussion was really interesting, and cleared a lot of doubts
Another video showing the
Another video showing the people in black (Anarchists, rightists, fash? Not saying this to wind anyone up) antagonizing, provoking....and throwing rocks at the KKE workers?
However much you disagree with what was happening in relation to 'protecting parliament' or whatever - I don't fully understand the whole situation - it asks a lot of questions about violence within the working class.
From yesterday's Morning
From yesterday's Morning Star:
Does anyone have any idea who could be behind this? Anarchists, fascists, who?
Fyi, I'm not trying to shit stir.
Quote: Please fuck off and
Oh great, just because you disagree with it and doesn't fit the "Whooo, anarchists, fuck yeah!" image you've constructed, it's "disinformation"?
Either provocateurs or provocateurs who identify themselves as anarchists.
This isn't news people.In athens indymedia, i ~6-7 attacks on KKE offices have been reported.
evolve wrote: Some
evolve
.
Arbeiten
.
A rough translation of part of a statement from the "I Won't Pay" movement (They were also involved in the clashes. See the link to the alasbarricadas thread for a google translation of the full statement):
The part about "pieces of marble and molotov cocktails" seems fair enough to me. Apart from anything else throwing rocks and molotov cocktails at other demonstrators has to be wrong, however obstructive or provocative they are. This isn't a defence of PAME and the KKE or an argument that people shouldn't have tried to break through their cordon, or got into fights with them for that matter, just that some actions are unacceptable.
http://working-class-self-org
http://working-class-self-organisation.blogspot.com/2011/10/morning-star-supports-stalinist-lies.html
I think it is quite extreme
I think it is quite extreme to us to see such a division within a protest where one part of the protesters attack the other, but frankly, I think there's nothing wrong with using force if it is necessary against whoever try to get their control over the movement. Looking at the videos, there's nothing that supports the claim of the KKE/PAME. It seems that they already prepared to some confrontation with other protesters. And if the cops deserves to be pushed, attacked (and they do), than anybody else, who act as the filth, deserves no better.
About that video, you have to
About that video, you have to take into account that it is not taken from the start of the protest, tension had been building up all day until charges from KKE started. And IMO, one can't talk about provocation when the other group (I mean KKE) shows up organized, with helmets and sticks.
[youtube]MESW7O43Axc[/youtube]
In this other video you can see all the people that was confronting the KKE, There might been some fascists there, you can't tell their ideologies :lol: , but suggesting they are the anarchists, or the fascists is ridiculous, it's like the party dusted off the typewriters from the Spanish war and got to work.
Some guy in alasbarricadas made an interesting point suggesting the KKE was looking for making some political points, making sure the vote happened by blocking parliament and the celebrating its representatives votes against the austerity measures. And at the same time looking like te responsible party capable of carrying the struggle forward. They certainly are taking advantage of every twisting of truth they can make, even using the death of one of its comrades for some petty political leverage.
Also, they can't accuse anyone of agents provocateurs or fascists when they are giving the police their backs and the protesters their sticks. That's double-think like I haven't seen before.
soc: Quote: I think it is
soc:
Although very different, the 1976 South African uprising starting in Soweto, began like this:
(here)
Cops in Greece are obviously very different from cops in 70s South Africa, as are would-be leaders and pretend "communists", but feelings of anger expressed against those who claim to be on the side of movements but in fact do their best to repress them often get turned into physical expressions of anger. For us who don't live in Greece, we should firstly try to find out a bit more before jumping to blanket condemnations such as Mark's saying:
soc wrote: I think it is
soc
I'm pretty much in agreement with this - though the use of force against other protesters is a big step to take. It looks clear to me that the KKE/PAME were setting up a confrontation, for whatever reasons or calculations of political advantage. There had already been fighting in Ioannina before things kicked off in Athens.
soc
The question here is how far you're prepared to go. Can you really justify actions that risk people being seriously injured or killed?
Samotnaf
It's a long time since I've lived in Greece and I'm very much out of touch with what's going on but I don't have a problem with condemning some of the actions taken by people on my side. I'm not arguing for pacifism or saying that the anger isn't justified.
Just to clarify, I don't wish
Just to clarify, I don't wish anybody to get seriously injured or killed. I think it is the responsibility of an organised movement to find a way to disarm the police and anyone, who try to contain us. Disarming won't be possible without violence, but our aim is not eliminate, but to draw them harmless.
Stalinists acted as cops, so
Stalinists acted as cops, so they should be treated as cops.
And from polish perspective -
And from polish perspective - if during process of revolution or general disturbance they will somehow get to the power, all anarchists, socialists, democrats etc. will be jailed or dead.
It was true here in Poland no more than 20 or so years ago. We all remember here what they can do to us. I write this especially to greek comrades. This is not Kronstadt thing. It was only 20-30 years ago when stalinists like those thugs which you see at photos here were killing working class people in the middle of the Europe. Never forget about this.
The urban75 thread on this is
The urban75 thread on this is worth looking at - in particular the posts from Dimitris.
Dimitris
Edit: there's a response to this post from a KKE/PAME supporter here and a reply from Dimitris here.
Deeply agreed.
Deeply agreed.
Mark I see what you mean, and
Mark I see what you mean, and I respect your view (in the most non-liberal way possible), but shit, if you have like PAME, protecting parliament. it jut confuses the shit out of me. At the point when a group of protestors protects the state, how far can we presume they are 'on our side' so to speak.
Whats more damaging molotov cocktails at PAME or the restructing of the state to fuck over the people? (bit rhetorical, but I am willing to think it out a bit more).
strike of some sailors
strike of some sailors continues: http://communismeouvrier.wordpress.com/2011/10/22/grece-poursuite-de-la-greve-des-marins/ ... KKE/PAME and their nationalist allies only would storm the parliament when they could acquire absolute power
Al Jazeera documentary on
Al Jazeera documentary on Athens since the 2008 riots
[youtube]C45QKpGFy6w[/youtube]
Sorry but all of this
Sorry but all of this apologism for PAME seems like the thin end of the wedge for pseudo-Trot 'leftist unity'.
Away from Kronsdadt analogies and other such dead rhetoric, let's cast our mind back to something very recent and pertinent. 20,000 students and radicals marched on Parliament last December. If the cops hadn't have been there behind 3 lines of reinforced Herras fencing, several thousand of them would have stormed Parliament, disrupted the fees vote and (more likely than not) trashed it a bit too. If a cop had have died during that assault, we wouldn't have given a shit, surely?
I don't see how PAME were any different than the cops in this scenario. This was the day of a vote on austerity, after all.
I think what's starting to happen here is the rupture of the 'anti-cuts movement'. Worth noting that Stalinists also encircled the Portuguese Parliament to defend it recently.
But the contradiction is a
But the contradiction is a class one. Do you see the Police the same as workers who are in the CP? Most Anarchists on here seem to say Police are not working class, but I presume the workers of the CP are? This is important regarding the question of violence within the working class. I don't think you can just say it's alright to fuck them up (obviously they were being violent as well) cos they're blocking 'us' from storming Parliament.
There must be other methods with regards to workers in the CP not simply street fights, fire bombing their offices and so on.
But, I am not there so do not know the problems as it would apply on the ground, day-to-day and so on. I might have a completely different attitude if I was. Just asking the question.
http://www.europe-solidaire.o
http://www.europe-solidaire.org/spip.php?article23235
proletarian. wrote: But the
proletarian.
I do not know about the current internal situation of the KKE but during the 2008 rebellion, they lost a small number of branches due to the parties moderate policy and its denunciatiation of the movement, ... since the 1960ies, they periodically have lost more critically members but many of them (with the exception of the 1989 split which produced the NAR and some libertarian marxists) drifted towards "euro-communism" or "left socialism" and from there finally towards PASOK
proletarian. wrote: But the
proletarian.
Sorry, but this is really reductionist. I'm not sure how you're defining workign class, does it include Blackshirts? To me it's all about social role: if a cop can re-join the working class once s/he renounces his/her uniform, then conversely, organised politicos can leave it once they arm themselves in order to defend the state, capital and the austerity programme.
Well, much like you, I lack a lot of context, other than a perception of Greek 'anarchism' as being overly insurrectionist/fetishistic of violence. Not long ago we were reading of anarchists attacking 'rival' squats after all.
That said, I think it's very important to debunk the revisionist misinformation regarding the day in question, which carefuly positions itself on the shoulders of pre-existing stereotypes of "violent anarchists". Let's be clear here: those in PAME in Syntagma Square were the low cost infantry of the counter-revolution. They were tooled up and hyped up (just like the blacked up anarcho types in front of them), I'm gonna infer that negotiation or engagement wasn't a possibility in that moment.
Caiman del Barrio
Caiman del Barrio
Many of us would. But it's not because he was a worker, or anything about that. Only because class war isn't about killing people but to destroy their role as it is now. If a cop dies or just simply gets stripped out of his gear and removed from the area, the same thing happens: he stops being cop effectively. If there's an option for doing disarm the state thugs, that should be our choice. But we need to be aware that this judgment is easy from home: once the situation escalates to that point, keeping such a cool head is almost impossible.
All of the usual demonstration routes and locations are like a walk in the enemy's territory and we are lacking of the means to go ahead without furious anger and eruption of unleashed violence. These circumstances aren't the best for preserving life. :wall:
Though it's years since I've
Though it's years since I've read anything relating to these episodes and it's kind of straying into 'remember Kronstadt!' territory (though it should always be borne in mind), the PAME/KKE's policing role is reminiscent of that of the CPI in the 'historic compromise' in Italy in the 1970s, and Enrique Lister's/La Pasionaria's CP in Spain - appealing to the bourgeoisie against those uncontrollable anarchists/workers. I wouldn't put it past the PAME/KKE to recreate the Nazi-Soviet Pact with the Golden Dawn to 'protect the nation'. The PAME have made their bed...
Quote: you might be
- tptg.
See also this.
Caiman del Barrio
Caiman del Barrio
I accept your criticism, it is not simply who is and who isn't forced to sell their labour power but the role they perform e.g siding with the state in this instance. Of course Blackshirts may individually be workers but so what? There is nothing in their role that is proletarian, they are the exact opposite.
On the KKE: the lessons of
On the KKE: the lessons of proletarian history are that the left wing of capital will be the major bastions/defence of the state against rising workers' struggles. One could see this "national defence" in the protection of the parliament building organised by the stalinists.
About three weeks ago some elements of the Greek trade unions, involving the KKE I should think - but I didn't see the details, organised a "protest" outside the German embassy of firemen and police. If they weren't involved, the reinforcement of nationalism and blaming foreigners for the crisis (especially the Germans) is perfectly compatible with the politics of the KKE.
indymedia/tptg wrote: We all
[quote=indymedia/tptg]We all experienced the nightmare that the Greek stalinists in co-operation with other leftist trade unionists and the cops created during the 48-hour strike in Greece on October 19 and 20 and some comrades in the anti-authoritarian milieu are badly wounded. We refer to the policing role of the KKE members: they were stationed in military formation in the area around the parliament, armed with helmets and sticks, facing the demonstrators with the riot squads behind them, preventing anyone from approaching, even asking for reporters' identities and attacking fiercely later those in the crowd who defied their cordons. As the clashes started, the riot squads came for their protection attacking people with chemicals and flash-bang grenades evacuating the area. It was revealed later that the stalinists had made an agreement with the police so as to be allowed to police the demo themselves. According to our information, similar agreements were made between the KKE and other left parties' or groupuscules' unionists so that each was alloted a special place near the parliament accepting KKE's hegemony. They later supported fully KKE in its denunciation of the 'anarcho-fascists', 'parastatals' etc, namely all those who were not part of the deal, not willing to accept it and tried to break their cordons.
As the capitalist attack deepens, this Greek style of 'self-policing' of 'problematic' crowd events has signalled the comeback with a vengeance of the left political parties and the left unionist bureaucracy against a proletarian crowd that had managed to escape their mortal embrace last June in the squares movement (albeit in a very contradictory way). We can't say whether this concerted public-order policing by the KKE and the professional police with the approval of most of the left and leftist organisations and unions is the visible part (in the streets) of a deal for a national unity government, but it certainly revealed very dramatically that the capitalist state has a lot of left-wing reserves as well as alternative police methods against us, as we argued in our two letters on the progress of our enemies ( http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2011/10/486344.html, http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2011/10/486740.html). Have a look at this extract we translated from an article in yesterday's Eleftherotypia, a liberal newspaper of wide circulation:
"It is obvious that attempts are being made at readapting the doctrine of the security forces' involvement in the social reactions, which will escalate continuously. A society that suffers badly from the economic measures cannot be beaten up by the forces of repression which have not found or do not want to find a way to isolate those who regard violence as an end in itself.
The events of recent days, if not marked by the death of the 53-year-old PAME trade unionist, could be seen as a sign of an effective change of the police doctrine towards a softer management of demonstrations.
Indeed, in those two days that police were fully in a transitory phase in terms of its leadership team, the risk was double. Initially, the apparatus was led for two days by those available since changes in leadership were announced simultaneously with the big demonstrations. And even with the participation of Christofareizis C., who was recalled from retirement, the designer of the MAT [TN: the riot squad] in the '90s, whose name was associated with the attack against pensioners out of Maximou [TN: the Presidential Mansion] in 1995. The other change observed was the return of the doctrine of self-control and inconspicuous granting of power to organized unions to self-guard the demonstrations.
What happened on Thursday with PAME guarding its demo not only in a defensive but also in an offensive way at the Unknown Soldier monument was the beginning of a new tactic which gives room for self-regulation to the demonstrators that will have the first say in the prevention of the intrusion of troublemakers in the body of the mobilizations. And this is risky, because the incredible violence between protesters, while the police was discreetly absent, could have had more serious consequences. Although any police involvement might have had even worse consequences. In any case this tactic is likely to be applied again after consultations have been made.
In this critical period it was clear that Chr. Papoutsis [TN: Minister of Public Order, or in the neo-orwellian language of PASOK government, Minister of Citizen Protection] wished for a softer administration at all levels of the Staff and not only at the leadership. That is why he transfered hardline officers that he thought they were damaging the image of the police due to the behaviour of policemen who had seriously injured protesters and professional journalists in recent months, during demonstrations. Obviously, for reasons of balance, the minister also hired an experienced veteran and put him in the position of the operation consultant.
For over a year, the minister has been talking about a lack of democracy in the security forces and has threatened that he will not hesitate to attack some structures, units and commanders. Certainly these commanders were appointed by the same government two years ago, when the offensive doctrine was applied for the regaining of the streets, according to the official announcement that had been made then.
The murder of student Al. Grigoropoulos had repercussions on the police as they were delegitimised in huge parts of the society, i.e. they were marginalized socially and professionally. There is an attempt now by the Ministry of Citizen Protection to reverse this disturbance of professional self-image and behaviour, in the worst period in decades, as the economic crisis is ruining people and cracks in social cohesion are increasing." [TN: It is not surprising then that some riot squads were telling the demonstrators that they were there for their protection!]
(Greek Police: softly-softly is the new doctrine, Eleftherotypia, 23/11/2011)
However, the struggle against the cops of all colours and their diverse methods as well as against the capitalist attack on the working class goes on!
TPTG
TPTG
- e-mail: [email protected]
- Homepage: www.tptg.gr [/quote]
I think as a movement gathers momentum, as it is clearly the case in Greece, the nice and polite avoidance of leftists and anarchist vanishes. As far as everything is ineffectual, we can wave our flags next to the trot or stalinists, but as things get more rough, these bastards show their true colors. Again, nothing new, but it must be bore in mind.
baboon wrote: On the KKE: the
baboon
And perfectly compatible with the politics of the Golden Dawn - The struggle against Fascism begins with the struggle against Bolshevism
As to Samotnaf's most recent post on this thread, the role of the KKE and its associated lefts, unions, etc. (a fine 'Popular' Front) appears to be the logical conclusion of leftist/Labour/TU approaches in the UK, summed up in TUC = Tories' Unofficial Cops.
Solidarity with TPTG against cop collaborators.
Agree with soc here:
baboon wrote: On the KKE: the
baboon
The real question is how far you're going to get by throwing molotovs at them. I also think the "Stalinism" of the KKE doesn't have all that much to do with it. I could easily see SIPTU in Ireland (despite no serious Stalinist affiliation) deciding to police a demonstration that they thought would erupt into violence in order to ensure to the broader public that they weren't violent trouble makers.
The development of "social war" seems to me to be a contradiction that will not be overcome by militancy in protests against the "left wing of capital", but in fact is just as likely exacerbated. It's not a question of moral correctness but one of proletarian progress. How might we overcome this? I suggest that it's unlikely to be overcome by bitching about "Stalinists" or by trying to beat them down in the streets.
In broad strokes we can see the decomposition of the working class into a unionised, older and more secure section trying to protect itself from deepening austerity through relatively tame measures and being at least somewhat represented by PAME. On the other hand a completely disenfranchised youth with little prospect of progressive change within the current system being pitted against the more comfortable section of the working class. How might we reconstitute this without devolving into a proletarian civil war while the ruling class walks away with the spoils?
I'm curious about what the average greek punter who isn't an anarchist thinks about what occurred. To me it looks like an excellent way for the media to demonstrate how divided and useless the left is, and potentially even worse, how little regard for human life the molotov throwing anarchists have.
Now some have said that those people throwing marble, who were clearly instigating a fight prior to the PAME erupting into response, may not have been anarchists. It's true, they could have been anyone from the fash to the cops. What I find more worrying is the idea that we should defend them. Whatever about the role of stalinists etc, instigation of violence in this scenario was at best a tactical debacle and at worst a long term injury on the prospect of proletarian struggle.
jacobian: Quote: I'm curious
jacobian:
You clearly haven't bothered to read the TPTG who are neither the "average greek punter" (a patronising expression that sounds like you're curious about Greeks going on demos to do their shopping, and not proletarian shopping either) nor anarchists; they said:
And the right-wing media praised the left wing of capital for protecting the bourgeoisie's parliament.
You really think the guy who died of a heart attack was the victim of those who have " so little regard for human life"?
Samotnaf wrote: You clearly
Samotnaf
I don't see anything patronising about wondering what non-leftist Greek proles think.
I saw the videos and its pretty clear who started throwing marble and other things as well as hostile advances, and who was trying to start a fight and it wasn't the PAME unless you equate standing in front of parliament as an offense punishable by attack.
The stuff about "anarcho-fascist" is clearly a smear, but lets face it, it was after some idiots threw stuff at them and began a confrontation.
When anarchists can manage to organise 415k union members in greece they'll be faced with whether or not to go ahead with general strike or whether they should storm the parliament provoking a potential military response and isolating the Greek proletariat with respect to Europe.
I don't see the point in trying to defend useless social war with nothing more than moral justifications and no prospect of success of any kind.
I think you have couple of
I think you have couple of good point jacobian, but let's make some distinctions here:
There's the demo itself. It wasn't organised by the PAME/KKE, but still they wanted to make a political score with policing the demo by themselves. I think, no matter who they were and what was the underlying reason, this act in itself provoking attacks from... not just anarchists, but anyone, who realise that this is nothing but appropriating the demo for their own agenda. In such a cases, violence is unavoidable, even more, it shouldn't be avoided, if the PAME or any other group doesn't stand down.
Apart from the protest, I agree: stalinists having big union support as they go for the most superficial defense against the austerity, therefore it seems the best solution for those, who already have a secure job for years or even decades. But, frankly, this is the key element in every parlamentary opposition force. The "left" itself constituted by unions and social democratic (stalinist, trotskyst, or more softy sd parties). So, of course in the large scale, you can't direct violence against just anyone, who belongs to these unions and parties. Nevertheless, that doesn't mean that the left won't engage in often violent actions against revolutionaries. If not their own ranks, than they will collaborate with the police for doing so. That is to say, to smash the socdem/bolshevik organisations is necessary, but of course can not be done by pure violence. That is a different campaign: it isn't enough just to reveal their inherent reformist agenda, which is aimed to get in power as much as other political parties. The sharp difference between the younger and older generation of workers is alarming, simply because the older generation in the working class has more to fear: those must be addressed with the building of anarchist organisations.
Anarchists are key element in any movement to contest the very idea of "professional" leadership, and we must continue doing so in many ways. Stand firm in terms of organisation, propaganda and only ultimately violence.
jacobian wrote: I saw the
jacobian
Sorry wtf? They were tooled up, in the SECOND DAY of defending Parliament so that the latest austerity bill could pass. Another Greek poster has already said on here that the videos don't include earlier clashes between the blocs.
Caiman del Barrio
Caiman del Barrio
Ok, so someone suggested that the videos don't show everything, so it's possible the PAME started it. I don't think that's as likely but it's possible.
Supposing it is true though. All the rest of the problems of intra-class war still stand.
In addition certain anarchists have been stating that the guarding of the parliament was sufficient grounds for attack. Were they?
Really I think this immediate response from several anarchists makes the likelihood that the PAME started it even lower.
Quote: In addition certain
The parliament was about to accept the next round of austerity measures. The crowd (and not only anarchists!) was tying to storm the parliament several times before, and those weren't really anarchists only. Many times even the PAME had hard time to hold their membership back.
If the cops are defending it, the crowd attacks the cops. If the PAME was organising the defense of the parliament that ends up with the same effect.
If the crowd would storm the parliament we would talk about a lot of new possibilities now. But given that it wasn't only the cops who stopped this happening, but "fellow protesters" with their MPs in the parliament I can not see anything wrong that those "protesters" were effectively against the tide.
You give too much credit to who started the actual confrontation. Doesn't matter if the "anarchists" tried to break up the PAME lines or not, they were in the way to stop the vote happening in the first place, and this intention was clear. So, what is the difference in this particular situation between the police and the red-flagged "protesters"? IMO nothing, nothing at all.
Oh, and as for the avarage
Oh, and as for the avarage greek punter:
[youtube]7OvModwZRWI[/youtube]
Quote: @KriegPhilosophy: That
Stalinists in Greece have been the enemies of anarchists for almost a century, have you forgotten history? KKE in the past have defended police from petrol bombing attacks and have tried to de-mask and beat militants who were organizing to mount assaults on police lines.
Ever since the fall of the junta the KKE have been increasingly supportive of the democratic state in greece. Also this is not the first time anarchists have attacked the KKE; when the uprisings in Poland occurred against soviet rule anarchists petrol bombed the offices!
Stalinists are our mutual enemies and anarchist-syndicalists who co-operate with PAME should not forget the lessons of the thirties.
KKE knew exactly what they were doing when they surrounded the parliament, to protect state from any symbolic or physical damage.
The only reason Stalinist's are not attacked in England is because they are an insignificant political force.
soc wrote: If the crowd
soc
Really? What possibilities would those be? If most people in Greece think the best bet is slightly reduced austerity (something made plausible by who is actually in parliament) it seems a move to take parliament like this would be little more than adventurism.
Worst case scenarios are very easy to imagine, if they actually succeeded in shutting down parliament. Namely a military crackdown against a faction of the working class that doesn't have sufficient economic traction in the unions much less a force capable of countering repression. Further negative consequences could include isolation from a Euro bailout and a concerted international financial attack.
As for the average greek punter, single data points don't tell us much. I'd like to see more broadly how people feel then one old lady.
A volunteerist revolutionary strategy from a vantage of weakness seems ill advised at best.
soc
Actually I don't. As I pointed out, it had nowhere to go regardless of who started it.
I do think it's an important question what to do about more conservative sections of the proletariat. Certainly you don't think the PAME represents the most conservative end do you? And if it's OK to attack them, who else and under what conditions? And where does that lead?
jacobian wrote: If most
jacobian
I can't see that this would be the case. But it's almost impossible to prove or prove the opposite. They have a big burden, the government wants and actually passes these laws. (as they actually did again). So even if the majority of the greeks wants reduced austerity, it doesn't happen. And, as I pointed out earlier, the demonstrators did actually try to storm the parliament many times before, which shows that lot of protesters are to shut down the parliament. As for the rest of the population, given that the politicians are quite in danger (including KKE MPs) on the streets of Athens, I wouldn't be so sure that the majority of the people doesn't want to see the government and the MPs at least beaten up after what they did. But either way, in the first case, I was arguing on the behaviour of the protesters and participants of the clashes, and really doesn't matter, what the rest of the population wants within this scope.
I'm not sure what is your point with your projections. So... we shouldn't do a thing just because it could get rough? Perhaps we should wait until the "right time" comes?
Your last question is important. Stalinist formations are as much counter-revolutionary as the rest of the bourgeoisie. But surely, avoiding the confrontation with them, as they clearly go militant, is not the way forward.
KriegPhilosophy
KriegPhilosophy
First, I don't think the KKE are really that Stalinist anymore. Euro-communists who have drifted into the vacuum left by social democracies drift into neo-liberalism seems more likely.
Secondly I'm not really that sure that the PAME are that Stalinist compared to the KKE. I'd like to hear more from Greeks who actually know, but I think it's unlikely that you could have 400k people who had that much love for Stalin.
Third, if I'm wrong, and they are actual ML Stalinist reactionaries, then the anarchists in Greece have an immense problem on their hands and the current conversation looks utterly weird as a reaction to it. Who are you trying to convince that the conflict was necessary? The argument that it's a historical conflict isn't likely to win supporters from the rest of the class.
In any case complaining about their superior forces and their willingness to engage in conflicts which you can't win and which are likely to push moderate supporters into even more retrenched anti-anarchist positions seems totally useless.
Some sort of vision of how to deal with the balance of forces for class recomposition seems to me to be completely missing.
soc wrote: I'm not sure what
soc
You shouldn't do something if you have almost a 100% probability of failure. If you think there may not be a failure you should have some idea what the potential outcomes which aren't total failure would look like and what you would do with them.
soc wrote: Your last question
soc
Which is more counter-revolutionary, the PAME or the GSEE.
Deleted
Deleted
jacobian wrote: soc
jacobian
jacobian
Quote: First, I don't think
SYRIZA have a far more stronger euro-communist presence than that of the KKE, mainly because euro-communism goes against KKE party line (Marxist-Leninism).
The contemporary meaning of the word Stalinism doesn't necessarily mean embracing the cult of personality that it classically represented(even though placards of Stalin have been see at KKE demonstrations), especially with the fall of the soviet union. Rather it means anti-revisionism, anti-trotskyist, Marxist-Leninist and authoritarianism. I'm pretty sure the KKE have a pretty strong grip on the rank and file of their own union and just because they are militant doesn't make them deviate from their party.
No the anarchists/ anti-authoritarians/Autonomists do not have a problem when they are fighting the authoritarians mainly because they know from what history has taught them that compromise is not an option. Also our ideas are in the hearts of the majority of the youth and 30-40 years down the line the Stalinist's will be simply a shadow of what they once were. Who are you trying to convince that the confrontation was unnecessary? Why won't the historical argument win supporters? Because if people investigate for themselves the trend of the relationship between the Institutionalised Left and the radical movement they will see that the attacks and the aggressiveness of the radicals are completely justified.
What "superior forces" exactly? The KKE/PAME security detachment were eventually booed by the "Non-anarchist moderate" crowd who were looking on the conflict, mainly because anarchists weren't randomly beating bystanders; it was the riot police and the red flag holding Stalinist's.
What does that even mean ffs?
KriegPhilosophy wrote: that
KriegPhilosophy
You already answered the question. Your plan appears to be waiting 30-40 years for the Stalinists to die.
Quote: You already answered
Oh yes of course. :roll:No I just don't believe that revolution is around the corner (in Greece that is), Civil war maybe in 5-10 years time but it's going to be extremely bloody, drawn out and may lead to dictatorship. I'd rather wait 30-40 years with a strategy of tension than go into full industrial conflict.
a few general remarks about
a few general remarks about the KKE:
- unlike all other major CPs in Europe (even compared with those who show strong similarities eg the Czech or the Portuguese one), the KKE openly identifies with Stalin see e.g. inter.kke.gr/News/2008news/2008-12-thesis-socialism/
- it is not KKE/PAME/KNE against anarchists/anti-authoritarians, it is KKE and its fronts and "anti-monopolists, anti-imperialist allies" (a few nationalistic priests, businessmen, journalists, a few former local PASOK and ND politicians) against everyone else in the movement ... e,g, last Thursday, the KKE/PAME bloc first attacks were not directed against Anarchists but against members of the "I won't pay movement", see e.g. http://kasamaproject.org/2011/10/25/greeces-occupation-verdict-on-the-governments-leftists/#comment-45510
Just a quick note,
Just a quick note, Entdinglichung: I don't think the Czech CP (KSČM) bears strong similarities to KKE. It has no workplace presence, no KKE-style militants, no real influence in the unions, negligible mobilization potential, and a pro-small business orientation. As far as Stalinism is concerned, it officially distances itself from it and calls for a "democratic socialism" respecting the "market laws". Of course, there are Stalinist and generally nostalgic elements in the party, but I don't think they can influence its politics.
Entdinglichung wrote: -
Entdinglichung
aside note: the big difference between greek and czech cp is that czech one is in no way rooted on workplaces like greek one and is not able to mobilize workers/youth like its greek counterpart. fortunatelly one should add.
Haha, guadia, I think we
Haha, guadia, I think we should establish Libcom office hours in KPK so we don't cross-post.
... hihi. not, it was just a
... hihi. not, it was just a short intermezzo in my mostly lurking habit here. now i have to prepare myself for the meeting anyway. :)
This is the KKE's statement
This is the KKE's statement on the story: http://inter.kke.gr/News/news2011/2011-10-21-murderous-attack-info
I have to say, this whole mess is utterly disgraceful as it is. I can understand the concerns of those who see the attacks against the PAME lines as dangerous as it is an attack against working class people. But, putting things in to context, soldiers, bailiffs and policemen are working class too, and they still brutalise, intimidate, or even kill other working class people revolution or otherwise.
One would think, that the PAME's tactic, to encircle the parliament sounds actually quite OK as far as "democratic protest" goes because they say, that was because they wanted to keep the MPs out of the building. The issue is, that there is some contradiction within these lines. They know, that such a measure is only symbolic, because the MPs can get in anyway, and not by chance, their own representatives. Aside from this technical issue with the explanation, there is the problem of how they behaved: they didn't let anyone close without party membership card. That is to say, they tried to appropriate the demonstration for themselves, in order to get a good media attention as we already used to this with any other opposition parliamentary force. So, their action was already provocative against anyone, who aren't of their ranks, aren't member of their organisations. Their "protection team" engaged in violence indiscriminately which is already fucking big contradiction to their statement.
But one should not forget how these "workers' parties" come about on the first place. As someone, who are from a country where their sister organisation was ruling for nearly 40 years, I completely understand how the anarchists' attacks were motivated. Anyone, who states that this current which the KKE is a part of, is anti-capitalist by any means, should rather re-evaluate her understanding of what capitalism is. These so-called Communists were responsible for utter exploitation of the proletariat during the decades of their rule, repression of any opposition (coincidentally, they called them bourgeois infiltrators, or fascists at any opportunity), terror against the unemployed, educated. These parties were not less nationalistic than their right-wing counterparts, with the only exception in regards of the USSR, which of course was due their dependency of the tanks and army of the SU. Revolutionaries were seen by these parties one of their biggest enemies with their phrases that the time for revolution isn't just yet here. Today in Europe they made their own adjustment to the new environment, embracing the petit-bourgeois and their nationalist, protectionist ideals, and offer a hard hand to manage the class conflict in their national reach. Though in most parts of Europe they became quite insignificant, in Greece they still hold their position, due the controversial situation that Greece has experienced during the last few decades. Greece didn't experienced the rule of Bolshevism as the eastern European areas, but rather the heavy presence of the western interest, well-served by the junta, which was favourable ground for the SU-supported party. However, their massive support was never enough to get in to power, and after the fall of the USSR, they went through the same transformation as the other Stalinist parties. In fact, many of the eastern European Communist Parties were rather took the KKE as an example, only that their fate was already decided by their own history as ruling force.
Spot how do they smudge the lines between proletarian and capitalist forces. The very word, "anarcho-fascist" betray their opportunistic nature which is so wide-spread in the left in general (as a good example, I could refer how in Hungary, whenever the conservative party comes power, the left obsessed with the comparison with Mussolini, fascism, and so on. But there are so many example.) The alarming feature of their rhetoric is the fact, that all around Europe there's a deliberately spread paranoia about police infiltrators, agent provocateurs linked to every violent eruption of the proletarian forces. Indeed, even the policing itself relies heavily on the movements self-policing, that is, keeping every event as ineffectual as possible. The non-violent features of the bourgeois parties (leaving the repression to the ideologically neutrally-depicted police-force) are at the focal point of the parliamentary democratic violence. In a parliamentary democracy, any attempt to overthrow the political system becomes a "simple crime" by law, merged in to the pool of anti-social behavior which always have a scientific, "neutral" description, thus the confrontation with it on a political level can be avoided.
We have already seen many times how this system of "non-violence" succeeded in fragile political situations. "Non-violence" becomes a good excuse for institutionalized violence by the state, who doesn't have to rely on agent provocateurs if the crowd is already disarmed by the non-violent ideology.
What is going on here! Of
What is going on here! Of course standing in front of parliament with helmets and batons is grounds for attack! If the police were doing it this debate wouldn't even be happening. It is not that the police as people that are irredeemably evil, it is their social function as protectors of the state, capital and as agents of counter-revolution. PAME as the armed wing of the KKE* performed the social function of the police last week. I think the argument that they represent the working class is pretty weak and should be ruthlessly criticised. We all know what happened last time a group of Stalinists claimed to represent the truth of the proletarian. A cluster fuck thats what.
Just because a group claims to represent the workers (and may even hold the working class 'majority' in parliamentary elections) it doesn't mean that they actually do. How protecting the state at a time when austerity measures are going through can claim to be representing workers is beyond me (unless they are, in some marxio-machiavellian way, trying to force a real state of emergency. Which I doubt).
*An out and out Stalinist party lest we forget
soc: Quote: t the PAME's
soc:
I don't think anyone who was there in Syntagma who is not in PAME/KKE believes this: this is for internal consumption of the party base, and for potential voters - for the "average Greek punter", the spectator who never initiates or participates in any social contestation, but who follows, the mythical Joe Average that jacobian wants to appeal to to justify his opposition to those fighting the KKE. It's a Leftist lie.
Samotnaf wrote: soc: Quote: t
Samotnaf
Interestingly enough, IWA members tell us that Parliaments were also surrounded in Barcelona and Lisbon (I think? Maybe Oporto) recently. In Portugal (as I have said), it was a Stalinist con trick comparable with what happened in Athens, whereas in Barcelona, it appeared to be a genuine attempt at 'non-violent' disruption by the 15M movement, with CNT members participating.
I think that one of the
I think that one of the questions posed is that is workers attacking other workers, even if duped by stalinism, positive or negative for the movement overall? Negative I would say.
It raises a further question which is is the parliament business a pointless sideshow anyway and that the real needs for the development of the struggle lie elsewhere? I would think that they do.
baboon wrote: I think that
baboon
Nicely put baboon and I largely agree. I just think its important not to fetishize (in the non-marxian sense) workers. But your post avoids both the traps of this and falling into choosing sides (not like my last post that was probably overly partisan).
Some statements by Greek
Some statements by Greek anarcho-syndicalist groups. These are google translations which to be honest doesn't seem to work very well with Greek. They are critical, as I am, of the molotov cocktails and rock throwing - which doesn't change any of the criticisms of the KKE and PAME.
Rosinante
ESE Thessaloniki
ESE Ioannina
All i think of is lessons
All i think of is lessons from history, I'm not talking about Kronstadt, but maybe some should use that as a starting point and go from there into the history of leninist/stalinist history.
Another long post by Dimitris
Another long post by Dimitris on the urban75 thread
baboon wrote: I think that
baboon
This is the crux. My gut feeling is negative, but from where I sit it's very difficult to tell how negative it is. That's why I'm concerned to know what other non-PAME unions members think and what other demographics of the wider public think.
How permeated by Stalinism is the workers movement overall, the PAME specifically, and what will be done about this permeation. What means and methods have contributed to the enduring appeal of Stalinism. How will this problem be isolated and overcome.
I'm not particularly keen on the "we'll wait until they die" approach, as, depending on how the PAME are recruiting in the first place, it might never die.
Military parades cancelled in
Military parades cancelled in the Greek cities of Thessaloniki, Heraclion and Patras as enraged people storm officials’ stands
I guess this has been
I guess this has been escalated to a new national tradition ;)
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/10/28/october-28th-is-greeces-national-beat-up-your-local-politician-day/
More Ohi Day videos
More Ohi Day videos here
'Corrupt politicians, ensconced parliament, you will drown under the anger of the uprising'
http://storyful.com/stories/1000010455
Quote: Popular revolts and
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/10/29/popular-revolts-and-dentist-appointments-or-what-to-do-in-the-case-of-stalinist-betrayal/
Mainstream media on the Ohi
Mainstream media on the Ohi Day protests
http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2098138,00.html
Edit: also here
Edit2: from the Greek press Kathimerini ----- Athens News
Quote: This is the crux. My
Ah, I see what you're saying. What we have here is rather than just a class war, we have an ideological struggle for dominance. I suspect The KKE and it's front's recruit from the traditional industries that have not been yet subjected to the casualisation of work as with the service based industries where the KKE have probably been dominate since after WW2 and the civil war.
The reason I say that "waiting" is a good idea is because after Neo-liberalism has gone it's course and achieved it's objectives with this first generation, it will have undermined the existing political establishment so much that this will allow the radical movement to once again be the dominant revolutionary ideology ahead of the traditional left. Also Greece has an anarchist tradition stretching all the way back to 1860 and Marxist-Leninism just as it did in most of Europe sprang up with the Bolshevik coup after the Russian revolution and most likely will subside along with the KKE unless it completely changes it's tune.
AJE: Greece to hold
AJE: Greece to hold referendum on EU aid package
Kathimerini: PM announces confidence vote and referendum
Athens News: Papandreou’s biggest gamble
Mark. wrote: AJE: Greece to
Mark.
(I'd love to see Merkel's face when she heard :D ). We're definitely into diminishing returns territory here. March's EU "comprehensive" deal lasted a couple of months until it fell apart and had to be fixed by July's "final" deal. But that fell apart within a month, by the time the rioters were on the streets of English cities at the beginning of August, the July deal was in pieces and France was struggling with rumours of a downgrade. Now the October "definitely the last one, honest" deal has lasted less than 4 days (and in the case of the markets, less than 24 hours, thanks to Italy's bond sale). At current trend rates, EU deals will take anything up to 72 hours of unbroken "up to the wire" negotiations in order to produce a brief fillip of market exuberance for about half an hour.
Who says rioting in the street achieves nothing?
Of course the promise of a referendum at some unspecified date in the future is a two-way gamble to a) get the pressure of the streets to ratchet down (to calm the nerves of the more rattled politicians and get them back in line to prevent the government falling); and b) to put the ball back in the Franco-German\ECB court to get a better deal on fiscal integration.
ocelot wrote: I'd love to see
ocelot
Reuters: Greek referendum ignites German anger, hammers markets
Guardian: Greek referendum throws markets into turmoil
Athens News: Press Watch, Nov. 1
Hohohoho... if any one had
Hohohoho... if any one had any doubt before, by this time should have lost any illusion: real shit storm is under way.
Mark.
Mark.
G:
At this rate the coalition could be gone in the next 48 hours, before Friday's confidence vote or the opening of the G20 at Cannes this Thursday. (Is it only me or is there a grand irony in the spectacle of the neoliberal politicians of the EU grovelling before the Chinese Communist Party and asking if they could spare a trillion?)
Did I say 48 hours? Silly
Did I say 48 hours? Silly me.
G:
Meanwhile back at the ranch...
I make those rates currently 6.3171 & 1.8081 respectively for a 450 bps spread. Just to remind y'all that according to the LCH Clearnet ruling at the end of last year (that killed Ireland) Eurozone 10 year sovereign bonds that go over the 450 bps spread over the reference base (the Bund) for any sustained period of time, will trigger higher margin calls (the % you have to lodge with the clearing house against using those bonds for repos - cash loans) from 5% to 15%. This does two things - 1) The country in question is out of the game for raising bonds on the money market, 2) the local banks (who will have have high holdings of the local bonds to make the spread with the ECB base lending rate) will have to start selling bonds to pay the increased margin call on the loans they already have. And, to sum it all up, you're bust.
Presumably the ECB will go into hyperdrive to try and buy Italian bonds to get that rate back down, otherwise its bailout time for Italy, and possibly good night Vienna for the whole Euro shooting match (which is why they can't let it happen). I wonder who Merkel wants to kill first?
see:
Greek 10 Year
German 10 Year
G: Quote: 1.53pm: The six MPs
G:
Just in case you thought all
Just in case you thought all the exciting PIGS action was happening in the Med, Ireland has just announced that it has found 3.6 Bn euro (2% of GDP) down the back of the sofa. Accounting error apparently... (words fail me) :roll:
RTÉ
BBC Paul Mason, Greek
BBC Paul Mason, Greek referendum is coin-flip on euro exit
Looks like Costas' session at this year's HM conference will be pretty busy this year.
BBC: Peston, The price of Greek democracy
FT: Eurozone crisis live blog
Hmm. ECB running out of firepower on the Italian front?
I assume this gonna be a the
I assume this gonna be a the black Tuesday of our times... :twisted:
Well certainly a pretty
Well certainly a pretty overcast one ;) . However I suspect there will be more eventful days to come before this is all over.
In the meantime the Germans seem to be getting every PASOK minister they can find, on the phone*. Quite possibly to demand Papandreou's head. But on the other hand they've demanded that he appear in Cannes tomorrow to stand like a naughty schoolboy who's just set the class guinea pig on fire, to answer for his actions before a star chamber of Sarko, Merkel and the ECB. Which would be tricky if he's no longer PM by this evening.
If I was into speculation I would wonder whether or not Papandreou saw that he was going to be ousted by his PASOK rivals in favour of a government of national unity, and decided that if he was on his way out, he may as well be remembered as the man who got ousted 24 hours after proposing that "the Greek people" have a democratic say on the austerity programme - as a worthwhile investment for his political future. Pure speculation, however.
* Including to that loathsome slimey slug Venizelos who took to a hospital bed this morning to evade the flack, claiming he knew nothing about the referedum play. Not sick enough to be prevented from talking to the Germans on the phone though
FT earlier:
http://www.occupiedlondon.org
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/11/01/the-referendum-as-a-pacifier/
Hmm looks like the ECB
Hmm looks like the ECB managed to pull out enough firepower to get the Italian yield back down from 6.33 to 6.19, leaving the spread at 442 bps, just under the death zone level. I bet Signor Draghi's first day at work was pretty fun.
The whole military top brass
The whole military top brass has been changed. What's this all about? http://www.athensnews.gr/portal/8/49916
http://www.economist.com/blog
http://www.economist.com/blogs/buttonwood/2011/11/greek-referendum
http://www.forbes.com/sites/t
http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2011/10/26/the-real-greek-solution-a-military-coup/
In a similar vein, in
In a similar vein, in Italy:
FT blog:
And by "outside the government" I don't think they're talking about the Italian working class.
Quote: Despite the deep
http://greekleftreview.wordpress.com/2011/11/01/the-final-blackmail-of-baron-papandreou/
What the fuck is going on
What the fuck is going on with this spam filter?
dp
dp
newleftproject.org/index.php/
newleftproject.org/index.php/site/article_comments/the_long_goodbye
Still slightly uneasy that
Still slightly uneasy that there's so little comment in mainstream media about the military sackings story
Reuters: Opposition fury over sackings of Greek military chiefs
Which kinda makes it sound like it's become common practice for each out-going government to stack the military with their own loyalists to keep the other party in check. Even so...
http://internationalviewpoint
http://internationalviewpoint.org/spip.php?article2360
Entdinglichung
Entdinglichung
International Viewpoint
Any thoughts on this?
.
.
Mark. wrote: Any thoughts on
Mark.
Frankly, though it seem fair view in many respect, at the end of the day it doesn't really put forward any settlement around the events. First of all, the anarchist/anti-authorian groups and the fetish of violence isn't tightly related. There are plenty of counter example, if we look at the responses to the Marfin bank incident. But the use of violence, and the fetish of violence are light years away from each other.
The other problem is that there are always groups and individuals condemning the violence towards the PAME/KKE but none of these put forward any suggestion, how people supposed to react to the violence of the PAME and Co. I mean, ok, don't throw molotovs. But... to suggest that these thugs are different somewhat of the police is stupid. They were armed, organised, and directed against the protest. Wait... they are organised and directed against the revolutionary movements all the time! If they get in power you can see how they handle the proletarian revolts, just have a quick look back to Czechoslovakia, or Hungary. So is it fetish of violence to attack an already dangerous bourgeois force?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/wor
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/nov/03/greek-government-brink-of-collapse
sounds like a light version of a state of emergency ... with a government probably backed by all parliamentary forces from LAOS to DIMAR
Also from the Guardian Greek
Also from the Guardian
Greek crisis: finance minister breaks ranks over referendum - live
From the Athens News
Emergency cabinet meeting called by PM
Live news blog – November 3
Press Watch, Nov. 3
from a statement of the
from a statement of the maoist-left nationalist KOE (part of SYRIZA but probably not for much longer)
http://www.international.koel.gr/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=134:full-support-of-the-popular-protests-press-statement-of-koe-31102011&catid=17:2011-against-imf-eu&Itemid=13
Quote: After days of
http://www.occupiedlondon.org/blog/2011/11/03/national-unity-is-a-gruesome-trap-pm-papandreou-expected-to-resign-national-unity-government-lying-ahead/
-----
From the urban75 thread
Dimitris
from
from http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/blog/2011/nov/03/greek-crisis-referendum-eurozone ... it seems, that the bourgeoisie probably wants a (bonapartist?!) government led by an "independent expert":
From the Athens News live
From the Athens News live blog
Mark. wrote: From the Athens
Mark.
[/quote]
Popular Front-tastic. Looks like the KKE are angling to get inside the government of "National Salvation", or at least curry favour.
The deposition by Papadreou by Venizelos, (after his phone conversation with Merkel from his "sickbed" on Tuesday) - and what's simultaneously happening in Italy - looks uncomfortably like Merkozy-decreed regime change. In the case of Berlusconi, of course, it couldn't happen to a nicer guy (or one less despised by 78% of Italians at last count). But still, in the grand scheme of the contradictions between Eurozone economic imperatives and liberal democracy, it's a further escalation.
What's happening to
What's happening to Berlusconi?
from FT blog, re Italian/Bund
from FT blog, re Italian/Bund spreads
Uh... and this means?
Uh... and this means?
It means that Italy is on a
It means that Italy is on a knife edge of being forced into the same bailout scenario as Greece, Ireland and Portugal. Only difference is those 3 countries collectively make up less than 5% of Eurozone GDP, whereas Italy is the 3rd largest economy in the Eurozone, so the financial stress of any attempted bailout makes Greece look like a storm in a doll's teacup. Not to mention the massive exposure of France to Italy, debt-wise. Which is why "Super" Mario has spent his first two days at the ECB, buying Italian bonds.
see NYT web of debt diagram (US $ billions)
Which is the leverage currently being used in Italy to try and get Berlusconi out in favour of a "technocrat" caretaker government, which not coincidentally is also what they're looking for in Greece.
AthensNews blog
edit: If Draghi is now Super Mario (Guardian), does that make Merkel and Sarko Donkey and Diddy Kong, respectively?
edit2: oops, missed the significant para off that last quote. amended.
From the Athens News blog -
From the Athens News blog - looks like it's now down to the political horse trading
From the Guardian blog
http://www.guardian.co.uk/com
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/nov/03/greeks-austerity-grassroots
ocelot wrote: Mark.
ocelot
The KKE call to New Democracy members might sound surprising but at one point there was actually a short-lived ND-KKE coalition government.
Paul Mason - Il Pleut. Greece
Paul Mason - Il Pleut. Greece has poured vinegar on the G20's frites.
Mark. wrote: ocelot
Mark.
the KKE payed for this by losing the majority of its youth organization and several branches in Northern Greece
From the urban75 thread sihhi
From the urban75 thread
sihhi
Athens News blog
Anyway, the referendum will
Anyway, the referendum will not be held. Quelle surprise...
from the (more succint) talk to the party, before the parliamentary address:
Of course if there is consensus amongst the politicians, who needs to ask the people what they think?
Video: Crisis in
Video: Crisis in Greece
-----
Kathimerini: Bank liquidity at risk
So Papandreou has won his
So Papandreou has won his confidence vote - Athens News live blog
Mark. wrote: So Papandreou
Mark.
Never play poker with this man. Still, the setup appeared to be that he couldn't win the vote without a deal for a national 'consensus" deal with ND, for which he would step down. If he's wriggled out of that by Monday, I'll be suitably impressed. But let's see.
Well it looks like that deal
Well it looks like that deal is off...
From the ongoing
From the ongoing KKE/anarchist bickering on urban75
papageorgiou12
Dimitris
papageorgiou12
Disgusting. papageorgiou12
Disgusting.
papageorgiou12
I found it almost entertaining how bolshevik dogs like to think that they hold the eternal truth in their "party line". Everybody else, is infantile, stupid, ignorant, agent provocateur and we need them to "unmask" the parliament. They unmasked it so effectively through history, that when they took over, they continued to unmask it as they were running capitalism. Big fucking difference isn't it?
The EU is increasingly
The EU is increasingly showing it's regime change agenda. They started after the vote of confidence with the announcement that this infamous 8bn final tranche of the May 2010 bailout (originally due this September) would be withheld until "political stability" had been restored. Now today, Olli Rehn puts it on the table:
FT: EU steps up pressure on Greece
So no more money until Papandreou goes, basically.
Took long enough Athens News:
Took long enough
Athens News: Coalition government deal reached
Clinging to power? Moi?
in German:
in German: http://www.rsb4.de/content/view/4457/131/ an interesting piece by two anti-militarist groups about the Greek army and a European (German/Dutch) special police brigade which came into Greece during October for an "exercise (including armoured vehicles), the article also states, that the Greek government thinks, that it cannot rely on its army for a crackdown
from Guardian live
from Guardian live blog
Couldn't organise a fuckup in a nightmare...
ocelot wrote: from Guardian
ocelot
Obviously, not much efficient...Probably in the UK it'd be a "We-will-fuck-you-good-all-of-you-oh-yes" squad, much sooner..Would that please you more? :lol:
Kathimerini: Coalition talks
Kathimerini: Coalition talks fail to produce new PM, cabinet
From the Greek Streets: IMF representative “very likely” to become Greek prime minister
from the
from the Graun:
the KKE:
http://www.workersliberty.org
http://www.workersliberty.org/story/2011/10/26/greeces-rich-flee-will-workers-rush
Interview with economist, and
[youtube]C0JkSmoyYIY[/youtube]
Interview with economist, and former adviser to Papandreou, Yanis Varoufakis. Second part of the interview here. As my understanding of economics is limited I'd be interested in anyone else's views on his analysis (and proposals for saving the eurozone).
-----
Edit: Lucas Papademos confirmed as new PM
German workers hardly
German workers hardly exercise power over the German rulers; but still, his notion of appealing to the self-interest of German workers "over the heads" of the rulers makes some sense..
More from Yanis Varoufakis On
More from Yanis Varoufakis
On the Brussels agreement: Europe’s reverse alchemy in full throttle
The Lancet Health effects of
The Lancet
Health effects of financial crisis: omens of a Greek tragedy
-----
Athens News
In time of crisis, HIV gains ground
-----
From the Greek Streets
Far-right thug with an axe becomes new minister of infrastructure, transport and networks
'Then with tanks, now with
'Then with tanks, now with banks - uprising now'
Poster for march on 17 November commemorating the 1973 Polytechnic uprising
From Anarkismo Let's go one
From Anarkismo
Let's go one step further: On the present situation in Greece
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/1
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/13/world/europe/for-european-union-and-the-euro-a-moment-of-truth.html?pagewanted=all
more fascists:
more fascists: http://communismeouvrier.wordpress.com/2011/11/13/grece-lextreme-droite-au-gouvernement/
tr: Quote: Appointed
tr:
Athens News: Karatzaferis
Athens News: Karatzaferis denies he is antisemitic
http://communisation.net/The-
http://communisation.net/The-indignados-movement-in-Greece